THE SOUTH CHINA SEA is one of the largest semi-enclosed seas in the world bordering Malaysia, Indonesia, Brunei, the Philippines, Vietnam and China. Although Indonesia is not really a claimant State to the South China Sea, Indonesia has its shares of maritime claims in the South China Sea within the areas where Natuna Islands are located. Indonesia has yet to resolve issues involving maritime boundary disputes with all of its neighbours. Vietnam, Malaysia and China are good examples of nations with unresolved maritime boundary disputes with Indonesia.
Earlier in April 2019, a video went viral in Indonesia depicting a Vietnamese Official Fisheries vessel, believed to have been conducting illegal, unregulated and unreported Fishing (IUU Fishing) over Indonesian waters of the North Natuna Sea ramming into the Indonesian Warship KRI Tjiptadi-381 starboard side. This video has sparked anger and uneasiness among Indonesians particularly on the issue of Indonesia’s maritime sovereignty.
BACA: Indonesia kerah kapal perang ke Natuna berdepan China
BACA: Diceroboh kapal China: Jokowi tegaskan Kepulauan Natuna milik Indonesia
Recently, a number of Chinese fishing vessels and three Chinese Coast Guard vessels were reported to have entered the EEZ areas near the North Natuna Sea, agitating Indonesian authorities citing that China has violated Indonesia’s sovereign rights in its EEZ. China may exercise freedom of navigation in the EEZ area but are not permitted to engage in fishing activities. As a result of this illegal activity, Jakarta issued a diplomatic protest against Beijing and thereafter mobilised its warships to the North Natuna Sea to face China. China on the other hand argued that waters around Natuna have been their fishing grounds for generations, as it is within its alleged nine-dash-line areas.
In December 2019, China has protested against Malaysia filing a submission with the United Nations (UN) seeking to establish the limits of Malaysia’s continental shelf in the northern part of the disputed South China Sea citing that the submission had ‘seriously infringed on China’s sovereignty, sovereign rights and jurisdiction in the South China Sea.
The main questions to be pondered upon are to whom the EEZ area in the North Natuna Sea and continental shelf in the northern part of the disputed South China Sea belong to?
READ: Indonesia wants to rename part of South China Sea as Natuna Sea
READ: Indonesia vows to defend 'every inch' of territory
The Law of the Sea Convention 1982 (UNCLOS 1982) has created a number of maritime zones with varying degree of jurisdiction exercised by a coastal State. The UNCLOS 1982 provides that coastal States have sovereignty over its territorial sea that extends up to 12 nautical miles from the baseline. Within the territorial sea, a coastal State possesses sovereignty and absolute power over its marine area, subsoil as well as the airspace above it. Furthermore, a coastal State may make claims for EEZ (which involves maritime waters) and continental shelf (which refers to seabed and subsoil underneath the sea) in maritime zones beyond 12 nautical miles up to 200 nautical miles measured from the baseline of the coastal State. As far as EEZ and continental shelf are concerned, a Coastal State may only exert sovereign rights namely to exploit living and non-living resources in that particularly maritime zone. Unlike the territorial sea, foreign ships may exercise freedom of navigation in the EEZ area belonging to another coastal State. The extent of power a coastal State has in its territorial sea is much less in its EEZ and continental shelf.
Indonesia has yet to entirely resolve the maritime boundary delimitation with Vietnam particularly involving the EEZ area between the two States in the North Natuna Sea. This creates a ‘grey area’ where affected States may exert sovereign rights and this territorial confusion later creates ‘the blame game’ – both States may assume to have jurisdiction over the ‘grey area’.
In such uncertainty, Article 74 of UNCLOS 1982 provides that States shall make every effort to enter into provisional arrangements of a practical nature, which would serve as a temporary settlement until the boundary line is discussed and properly fixed by both nations. A very good example of the application of Article 74 of UNCLOS 1982 was a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) signed back in 2012 between Indonesia and Malaysia on the maritime boundary delimitation in the Strait of Malacca where the EEZ boundary line has yet to be fixed.
Until and unless Vietnam and Indonesia properly resolve maritime disputes involving EEZ claims in the North Natuna Sea, that particular area is open to be claimed by both nations. Indonesia has rights to send its vessel to carry out naval patrols while Vietnam may conduct activities allowed by UNCLOS 1982 in areas claimed to be part of its EEZ.
China on the other hand does not claim maritime areas around Natuna as its EEZ but as part of its historic waters within the nine-dash-line – the reason why they believe they have rights to fish there. This nine-dash-line claim was rejected by the Permanent Court of International Arbitration (PCIA) through an arbitral award issued in 2016 citing it to be against the spirit of UNCLOS 1982.
In addition, China has also persistently objecting to Malaysia’s submission to the UN in establishing Malaysia’s continental shelf limit in the northern part of the South China Sea.
The territorial hustles between Indonesia and Vietnam and recently with China are uncalled for. It is a fact that Southeast Asian claimant States do not possess as much resources and capacity like China in reasserting their territorial integrity in the disputed maritime area. As such, Malaysia, the Philippines, Vietnam, Brunei and now, Indonesia, should put their differences aside to face China particularly in developing the Code of Conduct (CoC) and the Declaration of Conduct (DoC) in the South China Sea.
South China Sea should be reserved for peaceful purposes and any arising conflicts must be mitigated to ensure that the spirit of UNCLOS 1982 is upheld and respected.
* Mohd Hazmi Mohd Rusli (PhD) is an associate professor at the Faculty of Syariah and Law, Universiti Sains Islam Malaysia.
** Dhiana Puspitawati (PhD) is an associate professor at the Faculty of Law, Universitas Brawijaya, Malang Indonesia and the Head of the Indonesian Centre of Ocean Governance.
*** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Prof Madya Dr Mohd Hazmi Mohd Rusli, Dr Dhiana Puspitawati
Sat Jan 11 2020
Indonesia has yet to entirely resolve the maritime boundary delimitation with Vietnam particularly involving the EEZ area between the two States in the North Natuna Sea. - FILEpic/REUTERS
Amendments to Act 588 passed in Dewan Rakyat
The Bill was approved through a bloc vote, with 59 MPs in favour, 40 against, one abstention, and 122 absent.
Americans face challenges as health insurance costs rise and delays mount
Recent data show that patients are now even more likely to have their claims denied, pay more for premiums and medical visits.
India questions Musk's Starlink for more clues in $4.2 bil drug smuggling case
Police seized more than 6,000 kg of meth in late November in a Myanmar boat carrying sacks of suspected contraband, and found Starlink Mini internet device had been used.
ASEAN must lead in navigating multipolar world - Mohamad
Foreign Minister Datuk Seri Mohamad Hasan urges ASEAN to embrace its diversity and adaptability as a model for global governance.
South Korea President Yoon banned from foreign travel as leadership crisis deepens
Yoon Suk-Yeol apologises for the botched attempt, leaving his political and legal fate to his ruling party, but has not resign.
Central Philippines Kanlaon volcano erupts, says seismology agency
The seismology agency advises local governments in the volcano's vicinity to evacuate people living near the volcano.
Official visit of the Minister of Foreign Affairs to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
The visit highlights Malaysia's commitment to boosting ties and cooperation with Saudi Arabia for mutual benefit across various sectors.
Selangor exco apologises over incident involving singer, local council officers
Datuk Ng Suee Lim apologises after a female singer alleged she was filmed by PBT officers during a massage at a beauty centre operation.
Two weeks on, flood-hit residents begin clean-up
Affected residents have begun returning to their homes to carry out cleaning and repair work.
Malaysia-South Korea FTA expected to be finalised next year - Liew
Deputy Investment, Trade and Industry Minister Liew Chin Tong says the FTA negotiations have already started.
Najib testifies: Totally insane to seek evidence implicating me
Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak argues that it made more sense to suppress evidence than disclose it if he were involved in the scheme.
Rapper Jay-Z accused in lawsuit of raping 13-year-old girl
Jay-Z denies the allegations on social media and blasted the lawsuit, calling it part of a "blackmail attempt" by the plaintiff's lawyer.
Motor racing - Hamilton says farewell to Mercedes with a champion's drive
Lewis Hamilton will be driving for Ferrari next season.
2024 will be the hottest year on record, EU scientists say
Carbon dioxide emissions from burning fossil fuels are the main cause of climate change.
MetMalaysia: Severe, alert-level rain warnings for seven states until Dec 11
The entire Kelantan and Perlis are expected to experience continuous rainfall at the alert level during the same period, says MetMalaysia.
[COLUMNIST] Trump's tariff threat: The timely catalyst for global realignment
It is becoming increasingly evident that even the edge of innovation is steadily shifting to the global South-East!
With Assad ousted, a new era starts in Syria as the world watches
International governments welcome the fall of the Assads' autocratic regime, taking stock of a reshaped Middle East.
Trump aims to deport all immigrants in the US illegally
Trump says he plans to also take executive action on his first day in office to try to end birthright citizenship.
Johor police detain 189 individuals in 'Op Noda Khas' crackdown
Johor police chief says targeted prostitution, GRO activities, and criminal gang operations at entertainment centres.
How Syria rebels' stars aligned for Assad's ouster
After 13 years of civil war, Syria's opposition militias sensed an opportunity to loosen President Bashar al-Assad's grip on power.