I hoisted my daughter off the pavement, perching her on my hip as I brushed the silky gold strands of hair from her eyes. At 3, Hannah was already getting too big for me to carry this way, but I needed her reassuring heft to ground me for the conversation we were about to have. Otherwise, I feared, I would simply evaporate into the sky. We were walking through pristine gardens toward the entrance of the Halquist Memorial Inpatient Center in Arlington, Virginia, a hospice facility where my 16-month-old son had been admitted two days prior. We had brought Hannah here to say goodbye to her brother.
"This is a special hospital, baby. It is a hospital for people who are about to go to heaven." The social workers had warned my husband and me to avoid speaking in code when discussing Luke's condition with Hannah. People died, they weren't "going to sleep." Luke was in hospice, not a hospital. I needed to clarify the shorthand we had been using the last couple of days, lest my daughter believe that every time someone she loved went into a hospital, they weren't coming out. This was especially imperative now, since, two days before - the day Luke was admitted to the facility - we confirmed that I'd be in a hospital in about nine months, giving birth to our third child.
Hannah's sweet face twisted into a grimace. Fat tears sprung from her eyes. "Luke's not going to die, is he, Mommy?" she cried. I was shocked by the speed with which she processed these thoughts: heaven equals death equals grief.
I looked straight into her sad eyes - we were both crying now. Answer the question that is asked, the hospice social worker had advised. Be direct. Be honest. Be brief.
"Yes sweetie, I think he is."
Even at the time, I was astounded at my ability to find the words to tell my daughter her baby brother was dying. It felt like the emotional equivalent of the mother who lifts an impossibly heavy object off the child trapped beneath. But although I hope to never endure a similar conversation again, I have followed that social worker's guidance many times since: Answer the question that is asked. Children, even at age 3, are remarkably disciplined about asking the question they want answered, and they have an enviable ability to accept that answer at face value.
So, several months later, as my belly swelled with Hannah's sister growing inside, I followed the same advice when she asked, "Mom, how does the baby get out of your tummy?" We were crowded into a bathroom stall at a restaurant; I could hear snickering coming from the next stall. After a momentary flash of panic about explaining the birds and the bees to my toddler in the bathroom of a Chili's, I paused, collected my thoughts and answered the question that was asked.
"I imagine she'll come out the same way you did - through my vagina."
Pause. Wait for the coin to drop.
"Does it hurt?
"Yes, but our bodies are made to do it that way. And the doctors help."
Pause.
"Can I get ice cream?"
Fast forward a year or so, when that now-5-year-old asked, "If all a man and woman do at a wedding is dance and kiss, how does a baby get made?" At least we were at home for the conversation this time.
I have employed the answer-the-question-that-is-asked technique on any number of dicey topics.
When visiting Luke's grave:
Q: "What is this stone for?"
A: "It marks where Luke's body is buried."
Q: "So his body is under this dirt?"
A: "Yes, it's in a coffin under this dirt."
Q: "But it's probably just bones and stuff now."
A: "Yes, probably."
Q: "Why are you crying?"
A: "I'm sad. I miss Luke."
And on death more generally:
Q: "Am I going to die?"
A: "Everyone dies sometime, but I think you'll live for a long time."
Q: "How do you know?"
A: "Most people live a long time, until they are old."
Q: "Are you going to die?"
A: "Sometime, but I don't think it will be for a long while, until you are all grown up yourself."
Answering the question that is asked is the first step. The tougher part is fighting the urge to elaborate on that answer once delivered. I think of it as a "full-stop" approach, requiring disciplined conclusiveness: Listen to the question; answer that question and that question only; full stop; wait for the next question. The strategy has enabled me to break down complicated, weighty issues into "bite-sized" pieces that are more manageable for a kid's developing brain to process. It gives the child time to digest the information she has heard and come back for more when she is ready. I have been surprised by the number of times Hannah has returned to a conversation out of the blue hours or even days later.
I have benefited, too. This technique enables me to give my kids answers without sharing my emotional baggage. Some of our conversations are fraught with emotional triggers, particularly when my girls have questions about their brother. But answering them directly and honestly and then waiting, sometimes with gritted teeth, for their next one forces me to follow my child's lead instead of going down the rabbit hole of my own grief.
It is not an easy approach. (Nor is it foolproof. Religion, I have found, is a topic that doesn't lend itself to short, declarative statements.) My husband and I want our kids to be thoughtful, well-informed citizens and believe we have an important role to play in their development as such. The "full-stop" approach can feel contradictory to our desire to engage with our children on matters big and small. But anyone who has ever asked their child, "How was school today" and been answered with only a grunt knows the futility of pursuing a conversation when the child isn't ready.
When I hear friends fret over initiating "the sex talk" with their kids, or struggle with how to explain the death of a beloved pet, I sometimes feel lucky to have already cleared those parenting hurdles, and to have had such good advice to follow in doing so.
These feelings of good fortune are bittersweet. I doubt any parent would have wanted to come by that advice the way my husband and I did. Luke's life was too short and too hard, but it wasn't a tragedy. Parenting him was the greatest learning experience of my life. Of course, the pain of missing him sometimes feels unbearable. So when one of my daughters asks a question that results in an initial "uh-oh" in my brain, I try to savor it, if just for second. It may be a hard conversation, but I know I'm not alone. Luke is right there by my side.
The Washington Post
Tue Jun 20 2017
Luke Golden; the author says his " life was too short and too hard, but it wasn't a tragedy. Parenting him was the greatest learning experience of my life." Pix by Janet Golden/The Washington Post
Is climate change making tropical storms more frequent? Scientists say it's unclear
Scientists say it remains unclear how much climate change is reshaping the storm season.
Samples obtained by Chinese spacecraft show moon's ancient volcanism
The material provides new insight into the moon's geological history including the oldest evidence to date of lunar volcanism.
The scamdemic targeting the young and vulnerable
Teenagers and young adults are becoming prime targets for a new wave of cyber scams, a trend raising alarm bells across Southeast Asia.
Japanese manicurist takes on plastic pollution, one nail at a time
Before global leaders address plastic pollution, a Japanese manicurist highlights the issue by incorporating it into her nail designs.
What to watch for ahead of US presidential inauguration
Here's a timeline of events between now and inauguration day.
The battle to reduce road deaths
In Malaysia, over half a million road accidents have been recorded so far this year.
Pro-Palestinian NGOs seek court order to stop Dutch arms exports to Israel
The Dutch state, as a signatory to the 1948 Genocide Convention, has a duty to take all reasonable measures at its disposal to prevent genocide.
How quickly can Trump's Musk-led efficiency panel slash US regulations?
Moves by Trump and his appointees to eliminate existing rules will be met with legal challenges, as many progressive groups and Democratic officials have made clear.
2TM: Consultations on PTPTN loans, admission to IPTA at MOHE booth
Consultations on PTPTN loans and admission to IPTA are among services provided at the Higher Education Ministry booth.
Kampung Tanjung Kala residents affected by flooded bridge every time it rains heavily
Almost 200 residents from 60 homes in Kampung Tanjung Kala have ended up stuck when their 200-metre (m) long concrete bridge flooded.
COP29 climate summit draft proposes rich countries pay $250 billion per year
The draft finance deal criticised by both developed and developing nations.
Bomb squad sent to London's Gatwick Airport after terminal evacuation
This was following the discovery of a suspected prohibited item in luggage.
Kelantan urges caution amidst northeast monsoon rains
Kelantan has reminded the public in the state to refrain from outdoor activities with the arrival of the Northeast Monsoon season.
Former New Zealand PM Jacinda Ardern receives UN leadership award
Former New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern was given a global leadership award by the United Nations Foundation.
ICC'S arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Gallant an apt decision - PM
The decision of the ICC to issue arrest warrants against Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant is apt, said Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
KTMB provides two additional ETS trains for Christmas, school holidays
KTMB will provide two additional ETS trains for the KL Sentral-Padang Besar route and return trips in conjunction with the holidays.
BNM'S international reserves rise to USD118 bil as at Nov 15, 2024
Malaysia's international reserves rose to US$118.0 billion as at Nov 15, 2024, up from US$117.6 billion on Oct 30, 2024.
Findings by dark energy researchers back Einstein's conception of gravity
The findings announced are part of a years-long study of the history of the cosmos focusing upon dark energy.
NRES responds to Rimbawatch press release on COP29
The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability (NRES) wishes to offer the following clarifications to the issues raised.
Online Safety Bill and Anti-Cyberbullying Laws must carefully balance rights and protections
The Online Safety Advocacy Group (OSAG) stands united with people in Malaysia in the fight against serious online harms.