The High Court here today struck out a suit filed by a dyslexic male student against the Malaysian Examinations Board and the government over the leaks in last year's Ujian Pencapaian Sekolah Rendah (UPSR) examination.
Judge Datuk Rosnaini Saub made the decision after allowing the Board and government's application to strike out the suit brought by K. Mangala Bhavani, mother to Ananda Krishnan Menon, 13.
She ordered the plaintiff to pay RM3,000 as costs to both defendants (the director of the Board and the government).
On Oct 13 last year, the student's mother filed the suit on behalf of her son claiming the defendants were negligent in conducting last year's UPSR examination, causing her son to have to resit several papers.
In the statement of claim, the Sekolah Kebangsaan Taman Tun Dr Ismail 2 student alleged that the defendants failed to implement a secure system to prevent the papers from being leaked.
Rosnaini in her ruling held that the plaintiff's claim against the defendants was bound to fail and clearly unsustainable and that it was an appropriate case for the court to strike out the suit.
In her eight-page judgment which was read out by Senior Assistant Registrar Mohd Isa Md Nor, the judge also ruled that the plaintiff's claim had no reasonable cause of action against the defendants.
Rosnaini was of the view that it would be stretching too far the test of reasonable foreseeability to say that the director of the Board, who was the first defendant, was liable for the psychiatric illness suffered by the plaintiff due to the leaks in the UPSR papers.
"The plaintiff was just one of the hundreds of thousands of pupils who were sitting for the UPSR that year. The first defendant may be responsible for the overall supervision and overseeing the UPSR, but it would not be fair, just and reasonable to place or impose a duty of care on her in respect of each and every pupil," she said.
Rosnaini said public policy consideration must also be taken into account because of the first defendant being a public officer.
She pointed out that even though the plaintiff's counsel was correct in saying that psychiatric illness was a recognisable damages in common law, in particular in the realm of tort of negligence, its recognition however had limits.
"As I have said, it must pass the test of both reasonable foreseeability and close proximity as described earlier. The plaintiff's pleading, in my opinion, fails to show this," she said.
In the suit, Ananda Krishnan alleged that the defendants also failed to supervise their personnel and agents from the start of the process to the distribution of the examination papers in order to prevent leaks.
The examination was initially scheduled for Sept 9 to 11, but students had to resit the Science, English, Mathematics and Tamil Language papers on Sept 30 and Oct 9 following the leaks.
Ananda Krishnan said as a dyslexic with special needs, he suffered from emotional stress, misery, disappointment and lost motivation to resit the papers.
He sought special and general damages as well as costs.
Both defendants in their statement of defence filed on Dec 3 last year, said they knew about the leaks involving English Papers 1 and 2 through news reports which showed the same questions as the actual questions.
Investigations revealed the matter was true and the board cancelled the papers and directed students to resit those papers.
The defendants also stressed that cancellation of the English and Mathematics papers were according to Regulation 9 of the Education (Assessment and Examination) Regulation 1997.
Senior Federal Counsel Kamal Azira Hassan represented the Board and government while counsel V. Rajadevan acted for the plaintiff.
Bernama
Thu Apr 02 2015
Ananda Krishnan had said as a dyslexic with special needs, he suffered from emotional stress, misery, disappointment and lost motivation to resit the papers.
Iran's supreme leader says Hamas leader's death will not halt 'Axis of Resistance'
The "Axis of Resistance", built up with years of Iranian support, includes Hamas, the Lebanese Hezbollah group, the Houthi movement in Yemen, and various Shi'ite groups in Iraq and Syria.
Putin says Russia willing to seek compromises between Iran and Israel
Russia is ready to help seek compromises between arch-foes Israel and Iran, President Vladimir Putin said on Friday, saying these would be difficult but possible.
What proposals will Russia push at the BRICS summit?
The proposal is also to establish a BRICS reinsurance company to allow uninterrupted shipment of goods and key commodities between members.
Indonesia's free meals plan in the spotlight as Prabowo readies for office
Prabowo calls the programme one of the main drivers of economic growth, eventually set to add an estimated 2.5 million jobs.
Astro AWANI's revamped English news website, AWANI International, launches on Oct 21
Astro AWANI's revamped English platform delivers in-depth global news and expert analysis to keep you informed on key developments.
Israeli strikes kill 33 people in Jabalia refugee camp in Gaza, medics say
Residents of Jabalia said Israeli tanks had reached the heart of the camp after pushing through suburbs and residential districts.
Liam Payne's ex-partner calls for media restraint after 'painful' death
Cheryl Tweedy used her statement to urge the media to remember they had a seven-year-old son, Bear, who could read the reports.
Analysts: Indonesia's strong MoF leadership team to boost investor confidence
Sri Mulyani Indrawati as head of Indonesia's Ministry of Finance is expected to instil confidence among investors.
Biden offers both a carrot and a stick to Israel as his term nears an end
Israel has frequently resisted US advice and has caused political difficulties for the Biden administration.
Putin says BRICS will generate most of global economic growth
Russian President Vladimir Putin will host a summit of the group in the city of Kazan on Oct. 22-24.
ISIS Malaysia's perspective of Budget 2025
An excellent rakyat-centric budget under the overarching principle of a caring and humane economy.
Budget 2025: Record increase in STR, SARA aid initiatives
The government will provide a significant boost to the Sumbangan Tunai Rahmah (STR) and Sumbangan Asas Rahmah (SARA) initiatives next year.
Budget 2025: EPF contributions to be made mandatory for foreign workers – PM Anwar
The government plans to make it compulsory for all non-citizen workers to contribute to the Employees Provident Fund (EPF).
What policies to expect from Indonesia's new President Prabowo
Prabowo will be open to foreign investment, his aide has said, such as by offering investors management of airports and sea ports.
Budget 2025: Govt allocates RM470 mil to empower women's participation in PMKS
The Women's Leadership Apprenticeship Program will be intensified as an effort to produce more female corporate personalities.
Israel sends more troops into north Gaza, deepens raid
Residents of Jabalia in northern Gaza said Israeli tanks had reached the heart of the camp, using heavy air and ground fire.
Indonesia ramps up security ahead of Prabowo's inauguration
Prabowo Subianto will be sworn in as Indonesia's president on Sunday with Vice President-elect, Gibran Rakabuming Raka, also taking office.
Immediate allocation of RM150 mil for local authorities, DID to tackle flash floods
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim said this allocation is intended to address the recent flash floods that hit the capital and several major towns.
Budget 2025: Sabah, Sarawak to continue receiving among highest allocations - PM
Sabah and Sarawak continues to be prioritised under Budget 2025, with allocations of RM6.7 billion and RM5.9 billion respectively.
NFOF will be operational in November 2024 with funding of RM1 bil
PM Anwar Ibrahim said NFOF will support venture capital fund managers to invest in startup companies with RM300 million set aside for 2025.