KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court today has dismissed kindergarten teacher M. Indira Gandhi's RM100 million suit against the Inspector-General of Police (IGP), Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM) and the government for allegedly failing to arrest her ex-husband and return her daughter, who was abducted by him.
Judicial Commissioner (JC) Datuk Raja Ahmad Mohzanuddin Shah Raja Mohzan ruled that based on the evidence given to him, the efforts made by the then IGP Tan Sri Abdul Hamid Bador and PDRM were not indicative of any neglect of their duties.
"Having all that evidence before me and coupled with the fact that for the plaintiff to succeed in the tort of nonfeasance, the plaintiff still must demonstrate the existence of malice or bad faith. It is impossible for me to conclude that the IGP and PDRM did not attempt to locate the whereabouts of her ex-husband Muhammad Riduan Abdullah.
"I conclude that the IGP and PDRM exercised their duties in the manner they considered to be most appropriate. How they conducted their investigation is within their wide discretion, and I am in no position to second-guess them.
"Essentially, what matters to me is that there is evidence that an investigation has been conducted and is still in progress," said the JC.
JC Raja Ahmad Mohzanuddin said that neither the IGP nor PDRM have any ill intentions in this matter.
"Given the nature and circumstances surrounding this dispute, I made no order regarding costs," he added.
Also named as a defendant is the Home Ministry.
In the suit filed on Oct 28, 2020, Indira Gandhi claimed that the IGP had deliberately and negligently disregarded a mandamus order issued by the Federal Court in failing to investigate or take appropriate action to return her daughter, Prasana Diksa, who is now 16, to her.
In 2009, Indira Gandhi's ex-husband, Muhammad Riduan Abdullah unilaterally converted his three children to Islam without Indira Gandhi's consent before going to the Syariah Court to obtain custody of the children, but in 2018 the Federal Court ruled the unilateral conversion of the three children as null and void.
Prasana Diksa was taken away by Muhammad Riduan when she was 11 months old, shortly after he converted to Islam.
In 2010, the Ipoh High Court granted full custody of the children to Indira Gandhi and in 2016, the Federal Court affirmed the mandamus order issued by the High Court directing the police and the appellants to apprehend Muhammad Riduan and retrieve their youngest child, Prasana Diksa, to be returned to Indira Gandhi.
Indira claimed all the defendants had a role to play in making decisions or ordering PDRM to execute the committal warrant against Muhammad Riduan Abdullah as ordered by the Federal Court on April 29, 2016.
She contended that the behaviour of the defendants had directly caused her separation from her youngest daughter.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Fri Jun 28 2024

The High Court today has dismissed kindergarten teacher M. Indira Gandhi's RM100 million suit against the police and government. Photo credits - Bernama

1MDB: Azam Baki instructed me to continue probe until solid evidence was obtained - witness
MACC officer says Tan Sri Azam Baki said the information gathered during 2015 Saudi trip was insufficient and needed solid evidence.

Thailand receives 260 victims of human trafficking from Myanmar, army says
The massive repatriation comes amid a mounting crackdown on scam centres operating along a porous border.

All of Donald Trump's tariffs and threatened trade actions
Here is a roundup of Trump's trade-related steps and threats.

Jasin house fire: Man recalls last screams of wife, four children
The man survived but his wife and four children tragically lost their lives in the incident.

Egypt's President Sisi to stay away from White House if Gaza displacement on agenda
Egypt's President and Jordan's King urge that Gaza should be rebuilt without displacing Palestinians, the Egyptian presidency said.

R. Kelly's sex trafficking conviction upheld
Federal appeals court conclude that the singer exploited his fame for over a quarter century to sexually abuse girls and young women.

Trump’s tariff war pushes Malaysia to accelerate reforms - Rafizi
Malaysia is no exception, especially as we are a major trading nation and the US is one of our largest trading partners, says Rafizi.

Hamas says it will continue implementing Gaza deal, including hostage exchange
Hamas says it will continue the hostage exchange as scheduled.

Several injured after car drives into crowd of people in Munich
The incident appears to have affected people participating in a demonstration linked to a strike organised by the Verdi union.

Suspected gas blast at Taiwan mall kills four, injures 26
The blast occurred on the 12th floor of the building where construction was taking place, with damage starting from the 9th floor.

Hamas says it does not want Gaza ceasefire to collapse
Mediators are exerting pressure for the deal to be fully implemented, ensure Israel abides by a humanitarian protocol and resume exchanges.

Honda, Nissan scrap merger plan but to continue strategic partnership
Honda and Nissan will continue their strategic partnership in software development and other fields.

India's Modi brings a tariff 'gift' to Trump talks
Modi hopes concessions on tariffs, fresh business deals and the prospect of cooperation on China will win the US president's favor.

Govt continues to identify new strategies to ensure Malaysia remains a competitive investment destination - PM
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim says among the initiatives that has attracted investors is the Johor-Singapore Special Economic Zone.

Kevin Spacey faces another civil sexual assault lawsuit in UK
Kevin Spacey faces British lawsuit over sexual abuse claims, just over 18 months after being cleared in a high-profile criminal trial.

Malaysia must fully leverage its strong aerospace ecosystem - MITI
The aerospace industry aims to increase its revenue to RM55 billion by 2030 from a revenue of around RM20-21 billion currently, MITI says.

Israel seen as likely to attack Iran by midyear, Washington Post reports
US intelligence warns that Israel is likely to launch a preemptive attack on Iran's nuclear program by midyear.

Trump: Not practical for Ukraine to join NATO, get back all land
Trump says it is unlikely Ukraine will get back all of its land.

Trump says Putin and Zelenskiy want peace; phone calls kick off talks to end Ukraine war
Trump orders top US officials to begin talks on ending the war in Ukraine.

Record number of journalists killed in 2024, Israel mostly responsible, CPJ says
CPJ accuses Israel of attempting to stifle investigations of incidents, shift blame onto journalists.