KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court here today ordered that a full trial be held on the defamation suit filed by kindergarten teacher M. Indira Gandhi against the Inspector-General of Police (IGP) and three others over the authorities' alleged failure to arrest her ex-husband and return her daughter who was abducted by him.
This follows the decision by Justice Mohd Nazlan Mohd Ghazali which dismissed an application by the IGP, Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM), Home Ministry, and the government to strike out Indira's suit.
In his judgment, Justice Mohd Nazlan said he found that the suit filed by the plaintiff (Indra Gandhi) for declaration and damages against the first defendant (IGP) for the tort of nonfeasance in public office and against the other defendants for being vicariously liable in respect of the enforcement of the committal order could not be said to be vexatious, frivolous or an abuse of the court process.
"This case is not obviously unsustainable to warrant a summary dismissal but instead should be allowed to be determined by way of a full trial where the parties will have the opportunity to call their witnesses and present their case. The striking out application is therefore dismissed," he said in a written judgment made available to the media.
Justice Mohd Nazlan said he found no merit in the contention of the defendants that the suit results in a multiplicity of proceedings in view of the existence of the judicial review proceedings at the High Court in Ipoh which is still monitoring the progress of execution of the committal order.
"This is primarily because both the cause of action of the tort of nonfeasance and the remedy of damages in this suit have never been raised before in any other proceedings. The plaintiff in the judicial review was granted the mandamus in respect of the committal order, which was affirmed by the Federal Court.
"That does not, however, bar the plaintiff from instituting a civil claim like presently to seek damages for the loss she claims to suffer as a result of the alleged nonfeasance of the defendants in respect of the mandamus and committal order," he said.
Meanwhile, as for Indira's bid to seek 48 answers from police over their investigations on her fugitive former husband, the court partially allowed her application, on questions related to committal proceeding.
"In respect of the application for the proposed interrogatories, apart from those relating to the recovery order, which cannot be allowed for the reasons stated earlier, several of the other questions, most of which require a 'yes' or 'no' answer, would in my view serve the legitimate and clear litigious purpose of the interrogatories to obtain admissions which would reduce the issues in dispute.
"The need to call additional witnesses would decrease and the examination of relevant witnesses would be shortened, thereby saving costs and expenses. It is also observed that in his opposition to this application, the first defendant did not aver that the answers to the interrogatories are deemed privileged," he said.
The judge ordered the defendants to pay a total of RM4,000 in costs for the striking-out order and RM1,000 for the interrogatories application and set Dec 15 to hear the suit.
Senior Federal Counsel Andi Razalijaya A Dadi and Federal Counsel Safiyyah Omar represented the defendants while lawyer Rajesh Nagarajan acted for Indira.
In her suit filed on Oct 28 last year, Indira, 46, claimed that the IGP had deliberately and negligently ignored the mandamus order from the Federal Court and failed to investigate or take appropriate action to return her daughter, Prasana Diksa, to her.
She claimed that all the defendants had a role to play in making decisions or ordering the PDRM to execute the committal warrant against Muhammad Riduan as ordered by the Federal Court on April 29, 2016.
The woman contended that the behaviour of all the defendants had directly caused her separation from her youngest daughter, who is now 13, to continue until today and that their behaviour had also caused Mohd Riduan to flee.
She is seeking RM100 million in general, aggravated and exemplary damages, as well as a declaration that the first defendant (IGP) had committed the tort of nonfeasance in public office, and the second, third and fourth defendants were also vicariously liable for the tort of nonfeasance committed by the first defendant.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Fri Jul 16 2021
The High Court here today ordered that a full trial be held on the defamation suit filed by kindergarten teacher M. Indira Gandhi against the Inspector-General of Police (IGP). BERNAMA
Delaware judge rejects Musk's $56 billion Tesla pay - again
The ruling by the judge, Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick, follows her January decision that called the pay package excessive and rescinded it.
French government faces collapse as left and far-right submit no-confidence motions
Barring a last-minute surprise, the fragile coalition will be the first French government to be forced out by a no-confidence vote since 1962.
Vietnam court rejects real estate tycoon Truong My Lan's death sentence appeal
Truong My Lan was sentenced to death in April for her role in what was Vietnam's biggest financial fraud case on record.
BNM issues three commemorative coin designs for sale until Dec 9
The central bank advises the public to place their orders through BNM's online system and not with or through any other party.
White House defends Biden's Hunter pardon as criticism mounts
Joe Biden says, he believed his son had been selectively prosecuted and targeted unfairly by the president's political opponents.
Malaysians return to devastated homes as floodwaters recede; more rain expected
In Tumpat, people return home to find many houses collapsed, with walls, roofs, and broken furniture scattered around.
King demands a stop to bullying culture at UPNM
Parents send their children here to learn to become military officers, not to be subjected to bullying, His Majesty says.
Son watches in horror as father swept away by currents while fishing
Muhammad Khairul Ikhwan says he was unable to help as he could not swim, and the incident happened very quickly.
AWS announces Malay-language gen-AI LLM, MaLLaM, on its cloud services
This aims to ultimately improve citizen communication and data processing capabilities across the culturally diverse country, says AWS.
Soldier found drowned, another missing during operation in Royal Belum forest
According to police, the victims failed to cross the river and were swept away by the strong currents.
Floods: Khairul Aming hopes for ongoing donations to collection centre
Khairul Aming says the centre is currently facing a shortage of aid items for flood victims in Kelantan due to limited supplies.
Another bleak Christmas in Bethlehem as Christian families quit West Bank
Bethlehem's Manger Square in front of the Church of the Nativity is largely deserted and souvenir shops are shuttered.
Global push for cooperation as space traffic crowds Earth orbit
More than 14,000 satellites including some 3,500 inactive surround the globe in low Earth orbit, shows data from Slingshot Aerospace.
Indonesia yet to agree joint development areas with Beijing in South China Sea, minister says
Indonesia Foreign Minister says no areas yet been specified to work with China on jointly developing fishing or extracting other resources.
Global South should unite in response to Trump's tariff threats on BRICS - Jomo
Jomo says there is a genuine opportunity to explore and expand possibilities within the system, provided there is a collective goal.
How Italy's tax system got rigged for the rich
Italy's tax system is skewed in a way that lets society's wealthiest 7% pay proportionately less tax than low and middle-income earners.
Monsoon surge from Dec 8-14 in eastern part of Peninsula - MetMalaysia
The concentration of wind is expected to occur in Kelantan and Terengganu from Tuesday evening until the early morning of Wednesday.
Australian social media ban started with call to act by politician's wife
The proposed social media ban held the door open for teens over 14 to keep using social media with parental permission.
New US solar tariffs on Southeast Asia to raise prices, cut profit margins
The new duties extend the United States' anti-dumping regime in Southeast Asia to solar cells, from just finished modules previously.
Vocational college student's murder: Victim was hit more than once, says friend
The 10th prosecution witness says was able to witness the incident a hiss view was not obstructed by any object as he was at a high place.