PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today ruled that Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak's conduct in relation to the SRC International Sdn Bhd case cannot be said to have served the national interests as it had turned out to be a national embarrassment.
Justice Datuk Abdul Karim Abdul Jalil said Najib was actively involved in ensuring that the RM4 billion of Retirement Fund Inc (KWAP) loans were disbursed to the company but, after the funds had been disbursed, the appellant (Najib) came indifferent to the whereabouts of the funds.
In a 54-page of summary judgment, Justice Abdul Karim said the former prime minister did not even ask SRC International as to what had happened to the funds, nor how it was utilised and for what purpose.
"He even instructed the second Finance Minister then (Datuk Seri Ahmad Husni Hanadzlah) to keep off SRC.
"This conduct of the appellant can be indicative of only one thing, and that is, once the funds had been secured by SRC International, over which the appellant had overarching control, he was free to utilise them for his personal benefit.
"This is manifested by the flow of the RM42 million from SRC International into his personal accounts. This is not something that can be said to have been done in the national interest. There is no national interest here, just a national embarrassment," said Justice Abdul Karim who delivered the verdict with Justices Datuk Has Zanah Mehat and Datuk Vazeer Alam Mydin Meera.
Justice Abdul Karim said the fact that Najib took part in the two Cabinet decisions to issue the two government guarantees to KWAP for the loans granted by KWAP to SRC was beyond question.
"The evidence shows that the appellant was not only present but chaired the two Cabinet meetings held on Aug 17, 2011, and Feb 8, 2012, and was thus involved in the decisions of the Cabinet to approve the said government guarantees in favour of KWAP," he said.
The judge said the matter was confirmed by Tan Sri Mazidah Abdul Majid (the 40th prosecution witness) who was the then Deputy Head Secretary (Cabinet) in the Prime Minister's Department.
"Mazidah confirmed that the appellant did not declare his interest in both Cabinet decisions, nor did he withdraw from the discussion in respect of these two items on the agenda, nor did he leave the meetings.
"Such conduct would militate against the appellant and would go towards establishing the charge under Section 23 (1) of the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) Act 2009," he said.
The judge said the court entirely agreed with the finding of the learned trial judge that there was overwhelming evidence which established the glaring personal interest that the appellant had in the Cabinet decision to issue the two government guarantees.
Justice Abdul Karim said the trial judge concluded from the evidence of the appellant's role and involvement in the establishment of SRC, the initial set-up grant, KWAP loans, government guarantee arrangement, as well as the ownership and governance structure of SRC, and the control of the SRC funds and the flow of some of SRC's funds into the personal accounts of the appellant establishes the fact that the appellant had an interest in SRC that was beyond that of his public office.
"We find no good reason to disagree with that finding," he said adding that the bench also agreed with the High Court judge finding that Najib failed to show his actions which led to the Cabinet's decision to grant two government guarantees were done in the interest of the Government of Malaysia.
The judge noted that in the present appeal, the involvement of the appellant in this criminal enterprise can be seen right from the incorporation of SRC International to the approvals of KWAP loans which were secured by the government guarantees.
He said Najib was involved in the approval, right up to the time a part of the SRC International funds amounting to RM42 million was deposited into his bank accounts for his personal interest and benefit.
Therefore, the judge said the bench found that High Court Judge Mohd Nazlan Mohd Ghazali was entirely correct in finding that the prosecution had proved the charge under Section 23(1) of the MACC Act 2009 beyond a reasonable doubt.
"The prosecution had established a prima facie case and the defence case was fully considered by the learned trial judge.
"In the end, the learned trial judge was satisfied, just as we are, that the prosecution had discharged their burden to prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt. Overall, we find that the conviction is safe," he said in dismissing Najib's appeal to set aside his conviction, jail sentence and RM210 million fine in the SRC International case.
Najib, 68, is the first former prime minister in the country to be charged in court and sentenced to jail.
The Kuala Lumpur High Court had, on July 28, 2020, sentenced Najib to a total of 72 years in jail and fined him RM210 million after finding him guilty on all seven charges involving criminal breach of trust, money laundering and abuse of position.
However, Najib will only serve 12 years in jail as Judge Mohd Nazlan ordered all the jail sentences to run concurrently.
The offences were allegedly committed at the Prime Minister's Office, Precinct 1, Putrajaya, between Aug 17, 2011, and Feb 8, 2012.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Wed Dec 08 2021
The Court of Appeal today ruled Najib's conduct in relation to the SRC case cannot be said to have served the national interests. - BERNAMA
Japanese woman charged with concealing baby's birth
Noda Junko pleaded not guilty to a charge of concealing the birth of a baby girl by dumping the infant in a shopping mall toilet in Cheras.
ASEAN Sec-Gen attends 4th ADGMIN + U.S. meeting
ADGMIN the U.S. is a series of meetings between the ASEAN Digital Ministers' Meeting (ADGMIN) and the United States.
Najib admits relying on Jho Low's assistance despite doubts and discomfort
Najib reveals that on March 6, 2015, Tan Sri Tong Kooi Ong told him Jho Low was guilty of wrongdoing and should be investigated.
Malaysia, UK strengthen trade and investment ties in inaugural ministerial-led Joint Economic and Trade Committee meeting
The UK was Malaysia's 21st-largest trading partner from January to November 2024 and the fourth-largest trading partner in Europe.
448 children from GISB homes returned to their families - Nancy
Datuk Seri Nancy Shukri assures parents wishing to reclaim their children need not worry and encouraged them to approach the ministry.
TikTok's fight against going dark gains support from key US lawmakers
The prospect of a TikTok ban has already triggered some users to seek alternatives.
China's population falls for a third consecutive year
The National Bureau of Statistics says the total number of people in China dropped by 1.39 million to 1.408 billion in 2024.
Hardline Israeli minister Ben-Gvir threatens to quit over Gaza deal
Itamar Ben-Gvir says he would resign from Netanyahu's govt if it ratifies the ceasefire deal in Gaza, which he has strongly opposed.
US says Gaza ceasefire to start as planned despite 'loose end'
We're tying up that loose end as we speak, says Antony Blinken.
Meta's 'Community Notes' model will not apply to paid ads
Community Notes on Meta Platforms will be enabled for organic content, posts that Meta hasn't been paid to promote.
South Korea investigators to file request to extend President Yoon's detention
Investigators must request court approval for a detention warrant to hold Yoon Suk-Yeol in custody for up to 20 more days.
Israel set to approve Gaza ceasefire, hostage deal, Netanyahu's office says
The security cabinet would meet on Friday before a full meeting of the cabinet later to approve the deal, Netanyahu's office says.
Bird feathers, blood found in both engines of crashed jet in South Korea, source says
Two minutes before the pilot declared the Mayday emergency call, air traffic control had urged caution due to "bird activity" in the area.
TNB’s UK venture in RE to benefit Malaysia in tech transfer - PM
The Prime Minister emphasises that Malaysia is actively seeking new investments in the RE sector, driven by robust economic growth.
PM visits Battersea Power Station, Malaysia’s iconic and largest investment in UK
Battersea Power Station is one of Europe's largest regeneration projects.
Meta in final process to obtain ASP Class Licence - Fahmi
The Communications Minister is also in talks with Microsoft as LinkedIn's Malaysian users may surpass 8 mln in the first quarter of 2025.
What can Trump do through executive orders?
An executive order is an order issued unilaterally by the president that has the force of law.
How many Palestinians has Israel's Gaza offensive killed?
This explainer examines how the Palestinian toll is calculated, how reliable it is, the breakdown of civilians and fighters killed.
How a TikTok ban would work - and why user workarounds won't
At best, users might be able to access a web-based version of the service that has fewer features than the app and even that might not work.
Trump considering executive order to prevent TikTok from being blocked in US - reports
The order delays enforcing the Jan 19 TikTok ban for 60-90 days, giving Donald Trump's team time to negotiate a sale or find a solution.