Is a standard template or app the key to bringing down legal fees? Would there be setbacks? Would the law become more accessible and understandable? These are questions both lawyers and public must weigh and consider before liberating the legal profession to non-legally trained Malaysians.
In principle, I agree that lower legal fees would mean better accessibility by ordinary Malaysians. It was argued that documents such as sales & purchase agreements, uncontested wills and probate, accident claims, divorce petitions, mitigation and bail in criminal cases are not as complicated as imagined, and therefore the public can cut down on legal fees through readily made templates and apps.
But before agreeing that templates and apps are a feasible move, it is important for the public to be aware and cautious of the possible pitfalls that might result in a layperson going through cumbersome disputes in future.
Firstly, it is important to note that not all sales and purchase (S&P) agreements are straightforward. Even lawyers at times, get confused with terms or phrases used. On top of that, ownership of a property is not the only thing stated in an agreement. There are rights and obligations of parties at stake which has to be consistent with the existing legal framework and legislations. Is the public aware of this?
To sink deeper into the mire, the laws governing the validity of these agreements differ according to states and places. Now, would a layperson be fully aware of these? The pitfalls are there. If overlooked, one might not even be aware of a breach.
To put these into perspective: A buyer of a newly built landed house might be able to draft a self-written S&P agreement, but what about a faulty land title which the layperson is not aware of? Or perhaps an apartment without a strata title which has changed hands a few times? Does a layperson know he risks being at the mercy of the developer’s prudence? Will he know the risks should he decide to resell the property in future?
Unlike applications or forms, a person drafting legal documents cannot safely complete an agreement simply by filling up the blanks. Lawyers are trained to deal with banks, proprietors, land offices, developers and most importantly, they are trained to foresee the risks and implications involved.
Have you not heard that even lawyers do run into trouble sometimes? When a layperson runs into trouble, where will he go? Back to a lawyer of course. At the end of the day, would it be cheaper or costlier? It very much depends, really. It is irresponsible for lawyers to lead the public into a minefield which might eventually expose them to more risks resulting in even costlier legal fees.
What about criminal cases involving the liberty of the accused? Would a layperson be able to fathom the factors and considerations taken into account by the judge during the mitigation process? It takes skills to persuade a judge, and these advocacy skills are not things easily grasped, even by lawyers themselves.
What about bails? Would the public be able to distinguish the difference between a bond and a bail? Or perhaps the difference between a bailable offence, non-bailable offence and unbailable offence? These are essentially important aspects of the law a layperson has to understand.
Secondly, it is certainly true that a liberalised legal profession would mean end users benefit the most. Generally, price will go down and quality will be improved when there is stiffer competition.
However, it is very misleading to cite the Alternative Business Structure (ABS) in UK as a perfect example for the public to do their own S&P agreements. The ABS which was formed in 2011 through the Legal Services Act 2007 allows non-law firms to own legal practices. It is a game changer not for laypersons, but for firms or multi-national companies to provide competition in the market.
As of January 2014, a report by LexisNexis has shown that 136 law firms (mainly small firms) have closed down. And in the UK’s case, it is because the big firms running ABS has gobbled up a big share of the legal services market.
These ABS ‘outlets’ are run by laypersons. There are strict rules and conditions attached to be fulfilled before a license is obtained, for example the strict requirement for a certain percentage of lawyers to be on board. They sit through courses and tests in order to obtain the license. Hence, are they really laypeople after all? Not really.
It is very easy for proponents to turn this into a rice bowl argument, but are all lawyers rich as perceived? Certainly not, because we are seeing small law firms closing down because they cannot eke a living. In the present system, the legal profession is an open market and you are free to choose your lawyers. If indeed lawyers are bound by the law to charge a certain percentage, then the problem does not lie with the lawyers but the legislation.
Accorded, there are lawyers who do not take pride in the works they do and only care about the overcharging perhaps, but that does not warrant for the whole legal profession to be undermined.
Look at the nitty-gritty and consider the pitfalls of it. Is it really feasible and beneficiary for a layperson? Ultimately, as members of the distinguished legal profession upholding justice, the worst thing one can be accused of is to lead the public into a minefield.
Adrian Lim
Fri Sep 26 2014
Who really benefits from boilerplate legal documents?
Thai resort island Phuket grapples with growing garbage crisis
By the end of year, the island could be producing up to 1,400 tonnes of trash a day, overwhelming its sole landfill, deputy mayor says.
Analysis - Biden to hand unfinished agenda to Trump for chaotic Mideast
Joe Biden's record on the world stage is likely to be heavily defined by his handling of the 15-month war in Gaza.
Biden administration will not enforce TikTok ban, says White House official
This leaves the incoming Donald Trump administration to make the decision, according to a White House official.
Hamas set to release first hostages under Gaza ceasefire deal, Israel says
If successful, the ceasefire would halt fighting that has razed much of heavily urbanised Gaza, killed over 46,000 people.
Pakistan's Imran Khan handed 14 years jail term in land graft case
Imran Khan's wife Bushra Bibi was also found guilty and sentenced to seven years in prison.
'It starts now': South Korea's President Yoon defiant as police closed in
Yoon Suk-Yeol remains in detention and is refusing to talk to investigators.
Japanese woman charged with concealing baby's birth
Noda Junko pleaded not guilty to a charge of concealing the birth of a baby girl by dumping the infant in a shopping mall toilet in Cheras.
ASEAN Sec-Gen attends 4th ADGMIN + U.S. meeting
ADGMIN the U.S. is a series of meetings between the ASEAN Digital Ministers' Meeting (ADGMIN) and the United States.
Najib admits relying on Jho Low's assistance despite doubts and discomfort
Najib reveals that on March 6, 2015, Tan Sri Tong Kooi Ong told him Jho Low was guilty of wrongdoing and should be investigated.
Malaysia, UK strengthen trade and investment ties in inaugural ministerial-led Joint Economic and Trade Committee meeting
The UK was Malaysia's 21st-largest trading partner from January to November 2024 and the fourth-largest trading partner in Europe.
448 children from GISB homes returned to their families - Nancy
Datuk Seri Nancy Shukri assures parents wishing to reclaim their children need not worry and encouraged them to approach the ministry.
TikTok's fight against going dark gains support from key US lawmakers
The prospect of a TikTok ban has already triggered some users to seek alternatives.
China's population falls for a third consecutive year
The National Bureau of Statistics says the total number of people in China dropped by 1.39 million to 1.408 billion in 2024.
Hardline Israeli minister Ben-Gvir threatens to quit over Gaza deal
Itamar Ben-Gvir says he would resign from Netanyahu's govt if it ratifies the ceasefire deal in Gaza, which he has strongly opposed.
US says Gaza ceasefire to start as planned despite 'loose end'
We're tying up that loose end as we speak, says Antony Blinken.
Meta's 'Community Notes' model will not apply to paid ads
Community Notes on Meta Platforms will be enabled for organic content, posts that Meta hasn't been paid to promote.
South Korea investigators to file request to extend President Yoon's detention
Investigators must request court approval for a detention warrant to hold Yoon Suk-Yeol in custody for up to 20 more days.
Israel set to approve Gaza ceasefire, hostage deal, Netanyahu's office says
The security cabinet would meet on Friday before a full meeting of the cabinet later to approve the deal, Netanyahu's office says.
Bird feathers, blood found in both engines of crashed jet in South Korea, source says
Two minutes before the pilot declared the Mayday emergency call, air traffic control had urged caution due to "bird activity" in the area.
TNB’s UK venture in RE to benefit Malaysia in tech transfer - PM
The Prime Minister emphasises that Malaysia is actively seeking new investments in the RE sector, driven by robust economic growth.