As China moves into the third year of its far-reaching anti-corruption campaign, experts and officials are worrying that without the grease of bribes, projects are stagnating and the economy is taking a hit.
Across China, more than 100,000 officials have been disciplined since President Xi Jinping's anti-corruption drive began, according to the government's figures.
As a result, many others are sitting on their hands, delaying decisions and failing to grant approvals for investment projects, either out of fear that they could be caught up in a future corruption probe or because, without a bribe, they simply lack any incentive to act.
The problem has become so severe it is ringing alarm bells at the top levels of government.
On Monday, Premier Li Keqiang demanded that local officials sign a written pledge to carry out major economic and social policies faithfully, saying that their dereliction of duty had slowed the economy, according to state media.
Some officials, he said, were "taking a wait-and-see attitude, being reluctant to implement major policies of the central government," China Daily reported.
Ren Jianming, a professor of clean governance at Beihang University in Beijing, said officials were not used to a system that ran without corruption.
"Developers don't believe that, without bribing, they would get a project, and officials don't believe that, without bribing, they could be promoted," he said. "They don't trust a clean system.
"Officials have stopped or delayed making decisions to avoid risks. Even if they don't take a bribe now, they might be suspected or reported. Then their previous corruption would be found out."
Graft has certainly not gone away, but the anti-corruption campaign has taken a toll on the sales of luxury goods and on business at high-end restaurants and hotels.
Some karaoke bars, where officials were softened up with alcohol and women, have closed their doors; the former Portuguese enclave of Macao has been hit hard by a sharp decline in gambling revenues, the mainstay of its economy.
The new reluctance among Chinese officials to act appears, as Li said, to have accelerated China's economic slowdown, although the exact effect is hard to measure -- not least because official statistics are not particularly credible.
"Anecdotally, this has had a real impact on investment projects [domestic and foreign-invested] for which approvals are not forthcoming," Arthur Kroeber, head of research at consultants Gavekal Dragonomics, wrote in an email, describing anti-corruption as "just one of a set of policies designed to slow GDP growth to a more sustainable rate."
Lu Ting, a Hong Kong-based economist at Bank of America Merrill Lynch, warned in a report last year that the campaign was creating "political paralysis" that was depressing investment.
He estimated at the time it could shave around one percentage point off overall 2014 economic growth, even if the figures reported by officials probably ended up being inflated for political reasons.
"Nobody wants to do anything," said one official in Beijing, who declined to be identified while speaking on a sensitive subject. "If we do things, we are exposed to all kinds of risks, including political risks. And we don't have financial incentives."
Ren said some hospitals had apparently stopped buying equipment because decision-makers were concerned about being investigated for corruption, while one businessman in Beijing said the campaign had not only depressed demand but also created new uncertainties.
"Before, when we wanted to get things done, we invited officials to dinner," the businessman said. "If they showed up, we knew things would get done. But they don't show up, so we don't know what will happen."
Minxin Pei, director of the Keck Center for International and Strategic Studies at Claremont McKenna College, says officials are engaged in a form of non-cooperation, of "passive resistance" to President Xi's efforts to overhaul the party.
"He has taken away their cheese without offering anything in return," he said. "They are saying: 'If you don't allow us to have a comfortable, corrupt life, we are not going to work for you.'"
Officials, Pei argued, know that the party's survival would be threatened if they stopped working indefinitely and the economy sank and are demanding to be allowed to return to their corrupt ways. "They are engaged in a test of will with Xi Jinping," he said.
Some economists argue that the anti-corruption drive will ultimately make China's economy more efficient and lower business costs, just as similar campaigns in Hong Kong and Singapore were credited with doing in the 1970s. Foreign business executives say it could help level the playing field.
"It takes the stress away," Joerg Wuttke, president of the European Chamber of Commerce in China, told Bloomberg last year. "You're not afraid that somebody gets an order because he found a better champagne or something like that. It's not Singapore yet, but it's a very positive development."
Meanwhile, Bank of America's Lu expects the campaign to have less negative impact on economic growth this year, partly because, having consolidated power, "the government regains the authority to either force or entice government officials to perform."
In addition, he wrote in a research note last month, "younger officials promoted in the past two years are either cleaner or are more loyal to the current government. These officials tend to be more proactive in boosting growth."
But others are not so sure that the campaign will have a lasting effect.
"The party knows it cannot totally clean the system because the problem of corruption has been around for many years," said Li Yongzhong, a senior researcher working within the anti-corruption system.
"It's a consequence of China implanting the Soviet system, with a concentration of power, and officials being appointed by their supervisors rather than elected. Without reform of the system, appointing new officials can only treat the symptoms. It won't make any fundamental difference."
The Washington Post
Tue Feb 17 2015
Across China, more than 100,000 officials have been disciplined since President Xi Jinping's anti-corruption drive began, according to the government's figures. - File Photo
Pro-Palestinian NGOs seek court order to stop Dutch arms exports to Israel
The Dutch state, as a signatory to the 1948 Genocide Convention, has a duty to take all reasonable measures at its disposal to prevent genocide.
How quickly can Trump's Musk-led efficiency panel slash US regulations?
Moves by Trump and his appointees to eliminate existing rules will be met with legal challenges, as many progressive groups and Democratic officials have made clear.
2TM: Consultations on PTPTN loans, admission to IPTA at MOHE booth
Consultations on PTPTN loans and admission to IPTA are among services provided at the Higher Education Ministry booth.
Kampung Tanjung Kala residents affected by flooded bridge every time it rains heavily
Almost 200 residents from 60 homes in Kampung Tanjung Kala have ended up stuck when their 200-metre (m) long concrete bridge flooded.
COP29 climate summit draft proposes rich countries pay $250 billion per year
The draft finance deal criticised by both developed and developing nations.
Bomb squad sent to London's Gatwick Airport after terminal evacuation
This was following the discovery of a suspected prohibited item in luggage.
Kelantan urges caution amidst northeast monsoon rains
Kelantan has reminded the public in the state to refrain from outdoor activities with the arrival of the Northeast Monsoon season.
Former New Zealand PM Jacinda Ardern receives UN leadership award
Former New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern was given a global leadership award by the United Nations Foundation.
ICC'S arrest warrants for Netanyahu, Gallant an apt decision - PM
The decision of the ICC to issue arrest warrants against Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant is apt, said Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
KTMB provides two additional ETS trains for Christmas, school holidays
KTMB will provide two additional ETS trains for the KL Sentral-Padang Besar route and return trips in conjunction with the holidays.
BNM'S international reserves rise to USD118 bil as at Nov 15, 2024
Malaysia's international reserves rose to US$118.0 billion as at Nov 15, 2024, up from US$117.6 billion on Oct 30, 2024.
Findings by dark energy researchers back Einstein's conception of gravity
The findings announced are part of a years-long study of the history of the cosmos focusing upon dark energy.
NRES responds to Rimbawatch press release on COP29
The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability (NRES) wishes to offer the following clarifications to the issues raised.
Online Safety Bill and Anti-Cyberbullying Laws must carefully balance rights and protections
The Online Safety Advocacy Group (OSAG) stands united with people in Malaysia in the fight against serious online harms.
Malaysia's inflation at 1.9 pct in Oct 2024 - DOSM
Malaysia's inflation rate for October 2024 has increased to 1.9 per cent, up from 1.8 per cent in September this year.
Saudi Arabia showcases Vision 2030 goals at Airshow China 2024
For the first time, Saudi Arabia is participating in the China International Aviation & Aerospace Exhibition held recently in Zhuhai.
King Charles' coronation cost GBP 71mil, govt accounts show
The coronation of Britain's King Charles cost taxpayers GBP72 million (US$90 million), official accounts have revealed.
Couple and associate charged with trafficking 51.9 kg of meth
A married couple and a man were charged in the Magistrate's Court here today with trafficking 51.974 kilogrammes of Methamphetamine.
PDRM to consult AGC in completing Teoh Beng Hock investigation
The police may seek new testimony from existing witnesses for additional insights into the investigation of Teoh Beng Hock's death.
Thai court rejects petition over ex-PM Thaksin's political influence
Thailand's Constitutional Court rejects a petition seeking to stop Thaksin Shinawatra from interfering in the running the Pheu Thai party.