BANGKOK: Few cases ruffle Hamid Ismail after nearly two decades as a lawyer, but he was taken aback when a man he defended was sentenced with the help of an artificial intelligence tool in the Malaysian state of Sabah.
Ismail knew courts in Sabah and neighbouring Sarawak were testing the AI tool for sentencing recommendations as part of a nationwide pilot, but was uneasy that the technology was being used before lawyers, judges and the public fully understood it.
There was no proper consultation on the technology's use, and it is not contemplated in the country's penal code, he said.
"Our Criminal Procedure Code does not provide for use of AI in the courts ... I think it's unconstitutional," said Ismail, adding that the AI-recommended sentence for his client for a minor drug possession charge was too harsh.
The courts of Sabah and Sarawak piloted software developed by Sarawak Information Systems, a state government firm, which said at the time that it had held consultations during the process, and taken steps to address some of the concerns raised.
World over, the use of AI in the criminal justice system is growing quickly, from the popular DoNotPay chatbot lawyer mobile app to robot judges in Estonia adjudicating small claims, to robot mediators in Canada and AI judges in Chinese courts.
Authorities say AI-based systems make sentencing more consistent and can clear case backlogs quickly and cheaply, helping all parties in legal proceedings to avoid lengthy, expensive and stressful litigation.
More than a third of government respondents in a global survey last year by research firm Gartner indicated that they planned to increase investments in AI-powered systems including chatbots, facial recognition and data mining across sectors.
This month, Malaysian federal authorities aim to conclude their nationwide trial of the AI sentencing tools, which they have said "can improve the quality of judgment", though it is not entirely clear how they will be used in courts.
A spokesperson for Malaysia's Chief Justice said the use of AI in courts was "still in the trial stage", declining further comment.
BIAS, MITIGATING FACTORS
Critics warn AI risks entrenching and amplifying bias against minorities and marginalised groups, saying the technology lacks a judge's ability to weigh up individual circumstances, or adapt to changing social mores.
"In sentencing, judges don't just look at the facts of the case - they also consider mitigating factors, and use their discretion. But AI cannot use discretion," Ismail told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.
Considering aggravating and mitigating factors "requires a human mind", said Charles Hector Fernandez, a Malaysian human rights lawyer.
"Sentences also vary with changing times and changing public opinion. We need more judges and prosecutors to handle increasing caseloads; AI cannot replace human judges," he added.
Seeking to address concerns that its AI software might lead to bias in sentencing, Sarawak Information Systems said it had removed the "race" variable from the algorithm.
But while "such mitigating measures are valuable, they do not make the system perfect", said a 2020 report on the tool from the Khazanah Research Institute (KRI), a policy think-tank.
It also noted that the company had only used a dataset of five years from 2014-19 to train the algorithm, "which seems somewhat limited in comparison with the extensive databases used in global efforts".
Sarawak Information Systems could not be reached for comment on whether it had since expanded its database.
An analysis by KRI of cases in Sabah and Sarawak showed that judges followed the AI sentencing recommendation in a third of the cases, all of which involved rape or drug possession under the terms of the two states' pilot.
Some of the judges reduced the suggested sentences in light of mitigating factors. Others were toughened on the basis that they would not serve as a "strong enough deterrent".
'OPAQUE ALGORITHM'
Technology does have the potential to improve efficiency in the criminal justice system, said Simon Chesterman, a professor of law at the National University of Singapore.
But its legitimacy depends not only on the accuracy of the decisions made, but also the manner in which they are made, he added.
"Many decisions might properly be handed over to the machines. (But) a judge should not outsource discretion to an opaque algorithm," said Chesterman, a senior director at AI Singapore, a government programme.
Malayasia's Bar Council, which represents lawyers, has also voiced concern about the AI pilot.
When courts in Kuala Lumpur, the capital, started using it in mid-2021 for sentencing in 20 types of crimes, the council said it was "not given guidelines at all, and we had no opportunity to get feedback from criminal law practitioners".
In Sabah, Ismail appealed his client's sentence recommendation by the AI tool, which the judge followed.
But he said many lawyers would not mount a challenge - potentially condemning their clients to overly harsh sentences.
"The AI acts like a senior judge," Ismail said.
"Young magistrates may think it's the best decision, and accept it without question."
Reuters
Tue Apr 12 2022
Malaysia is set to conclude trial of AI tool in sentencing. - Astro AWANI
Iran's supreme leader says Hamas leader's death will not halt 'Axis of Resistance'
The "Axis of Resistance", built up with years of Iranian support, includes Hamas, the Lebanese Hezbollah group, the Houthi movement in Yemen, and various Shi'ite groups in Iraq and Syria.
Putin says Russia willing to seek compromises between Iran and Israel
Russia is ready to help seek compromises between arch-foes Israel and Iran, President Vladimir Putin said on Friday, saying these would be difficult but possible.
What proposals will Russia push at the BRICS summit?
The proposal is also to establish a BRICS reinsurance company to allow uninterrupted shipment of goods and key commodities between members.
Indonesia's free meals plan in the spotlight as Prabowo readies for office
Prabowo calls the programme one of the main drivers of economic growth, eventually set to add an estimated 2.5 million jobs.
Astro AWANI's revamped English news website, AWANI International, launches on Oct 21
Astro AWANI's revamped English platform delivers in-depth global news and expert analysis to keep you informed on key developments.
Israeli strikes kill 33 people in Jabalia refugee camp in Gaza, medics say
Residents of Jabalia said Israeli tanks had reached the heart of the camp after pushing through suburbs and residential districts.
Liam Payne's ex-partner calls for media restraint after 'painful' death
Cheryl Tweedy used her statement to urge the media to remember they had a seven-year-old son, Bear, who could read the reports.
Analysts: Indonesia's strong MoF leadership team to boost investor confidence
Sri Mulyani Indrawati as head of Indonesia's Ministry of Finance is expected to instil confidence among investors.
Biden offers both a carrot and a stick to Israel as his term nears an end
Israel has frequently resisted US advice and has caused political difficulties for the Biden administration.
Putin says BRICS will generate most of global economic growth
Russian President Vladimir Putin will host a summit of the group in the city of Kazan on Oct. 22-24.
ISIS Malaysia's perspective of Budget 2025
An excellent rakyat-centric budget under the overarching principle of a caring and humane economy.
Budget 2025: Record increase in STR, SARA aid initiatives
The government will provide a significant boost to the Sumbangan Tunai Rahmah (STR) and Sumbangan Asas Rahmah (SARA) initiatives next year.
Budget 2025: EPF contributions to be made mandatory for foreign workers – PM Anwar
The government plans to make it compulsory for all non-citizen workers to contribute to the Employees Provident Fund (EPF).
What policies to expect from Indonesia's new President Prabowo
Prabowo will be open to foreign investment, his aide has said, such as by offering investors management of airports and sea ports.
Budget 2025: Govt allocates RM470 mil to empower women's participation in PMKS
The Women's Leadership Apprenticeship Program will be intensified as an effort to produce more female corporate personalities.
Israel sends more troops into north Gaza, deepens raid
Residents of Jabalia in northern Gaza said Israeli tanks had reached the heart of the camp, using heavy air and ground fire.
Indonesia ramps up security ahead of Prabowo's inauguration
Prabowo Subianto will be sworn in as Indonesia's president on Sunday with Vice President-elect, Gibran Rakabuming Raka, also taking office.
Immediate allocation of RM150 mil for local authorities, DID to tackle flash floods
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim said this allocation is intended to address the recent flash floods that hit the capital and several major towns.
Budget 2025: Sabah, Sarawak to continue receiving among highest allocations - PM
Sabah and Sarawak continues to be prioritised under Budget 2025, with allocations of RM6.7 billion and RM5.9 billion respectively.
NFOF will be operational in November 2024 with funding of RM1 bil
PM Anwar Ibrahim said NFOF will support venture capital fund managers to invest in startup companies with RM300 million set aside for 2025.