NEW YORK: As Donald Trump on Monday began using his time on the witness stand at his civil fraud trial to air grievances and avoid direct answers to questions, Arthur Engoron, the trial judge and a prime Trump target, decided enough was enough.
"Mr. Kise, can you control your client?" Engoron asked Trump's lawyer, Christopher Kise. "This is not a political rally. This is a courtroom."
It wasn't the first time the 74-year-old Engoron, a former taxicab driver who has spent two decades on the bench, lost patience with the defense in New York Attorney General Letitia James' lawsuit.
James has accused Trump, his family business, his adult sons and many other defendants of manipulating financial statements, asset values and Trump's net worth to defraud banks and insurers.
Since the trial began in a downtown Manhattan courtroom one month ago, Engoron has fined the former U.S. president twice for violating a gag order barring him from criticizing the judge's law clerk, and on Nov. 3 expanded that order to cover Trump's lawyers.
Trump, a Republican, criticized James while on the witness stand, saying the Democrat "should be ashamed of herself" for leading what he again called a "political witch hunt."
He was also unsparing with Engoron, a Democrat and American Civil Liberties Union member, telling the courtroom that on a question of law "I'm sure the judge will rule against me because he always rules against me."
During Monday’s proceedings, Engoron threatened to cut off Trump’s defiant, often rambling testimony.
When Trump resisted answering a yes-or-no question from a lawyer from James' office on the valuation of a Wall Street office tower, Engoron interrupted.
"We got another speech" from Trump, he told Kise. "I beseech you to control him if you can. If you can't, I will."
TRUMP'S 'FANTASY WORLD'
The criticisms mirrored displeasure that Engoron, who is hearing the case without a jury, has often shown the defense, last year holding Trump in contempt for ignoring a subpoena.
Engoron ruled in September that Trump's financial statements contained fraud.
That left for trial whether Trump and the other defendants should pay the $250 million in penalties that James wants, and whether to ban Trump from New York state real estate business.
Engoron's earlier ruling, too, was unsparing, saying the defendants lived in a "fantasy world" by claiming he could ignore any asset valuations, and that Trump might have built his fortune on something less savory than "savvy investing."
The notoriety of Trump's case is a big change for a judge who, while not shy about using colorful language in the past, has spent most of his 44-year legal career in New York out of the public eye.
In two of his recent higher-profile decisions, Engoron halted developers' plans to build a condominium on Manhattan's Upper West Side that critics called far too tall, and giant apartment buildings on Manhattan's Lower East Side.
Though both decisions were overturned on appeal, John Low-Beer, a lawyer who argued against the condominium, called Engoron "very concerned about understanding the case and the applicable law completely, and to get it right."
Engoron graduated from Columbia University and New York University's law school.
He spent more than a decade in private practice and 12 years clerking for a state judge before becoming a civil court judge in 2003. Voters elected him to the state Supreme Court, a trial court, in 2015.
Reuters
Tue Nov 07 2023
Former US President Donald Trump speaks on the day he attends the Trump Organization civil fraud trial, in New York State Supreme Court in the Manhattan borough of New York City, US, November 6, 2023. - REUTERS
Turkish ski resort fire kills 76, guests forced to jump from windows
The fire began on the restaurant floor of the 12-storey Grand Kartal Hotel, authorities said.
TIMELINE - Antisemitic attacks escalate in Australia
Police in the state of New South Wales, that has Sydney as its capital, have arrested forty people for antisemitic offences.
PM Anwar congratulates President Trump, looks forward to strengthened Malaysia-US relations
Malaysia stands ready to collaborate on shared priorities as Trump administration strives to herald a new golden age for America, PM says.
Trump's withdrawal of US from WHO to impact global health
Here are facts about US financing for global health and potential implications of Trump's move.
Indian state contests life sentence of murder, rape convict, seeks death, source says
West Bengal state launches an appeal to overturn a life sentence in favour of the death penalty for the convicted police volunteer.
A new American era is ushered in by a familiar Trump
Donald Trump promises a new golden age, casting himself as a uniter.
What ASEAN offers the world in the Intelligent Age
Under Malaysias Chairmanship in 2025, the focus on collective action, regional cohesion and forward-thinking strategies will be pivotal.
Trump’s second term begin with sweeping policy changes. Here’s what you need to know
US President Donald Trump began his second term with a historic wave of executive orders, reportedly signing up to 200 in a single day.
Trump administration canceling flights for nearly 1,660 Afghan refugees, say US official, advocate
The US decision also leaves in limbo thousands of other Afghans who have been approved for resettlement as refugees in the US.
Najib used Jho Low to receive 1MDB funds - Prosecution
DPP says Najib appears to be protecting Jho Low despite being given numerous warnings about his character and actions.
Investigation into Daim and wife continues - MACC Chief
Tan Sri Azam Baki says there were indicators suggesting the existence of foreign assets that need to be identified in relation to the case.
Gov't to replace toll waivers with 'more targeted approach' during festivals
Nanta Linggi says there will be no toll waivers, and 2024 was the last year for the provision of toll-free travel during festive seasons.
Trump announces 'DOGE' advisory group, attracting instant lawsuits
'DOGE' is run by Elon Musk and has grandiose goals of eliminating entire federal agencies and cutting three quarters of federal govt jobs.
Trump announces purge of over 1,000 Biden appointees
The step is likely to reignite concerns that the president aims to replace Biden appointees with individuals faithful to his agenda.
Trump revokes Biden executive order on addressing AI risks
Trump revokes Biden's 2023 order aimed at reducing AI risks to consumers, workers, and national security.
3M campaign concludes with financial literacy drive in Penang
The event marks the culmination of a series of initiatives aimed at promoting financial literacy and practical money management skills.
Trump curtails protections around diversity, LGBTQ rights
President Donald Trump orders that the United States will officially recognise only two sexes, male and female.
Childcare centre torched in latest antisemitic attack in Australia
It was the second antisemitic attack on property in four days in Sydney and comes amid a spate of similar crimes targeting Jewish community.
Musk's hand gesture during Trump inauguration festivities draws scrutiny
Elon Musk dismisses criticism of the hand gesture as a "tired" attack.
Hamas says next hostages will be released on Saturday as scheduled
Hamas is set to release the more than 90 hostages over the coming weeks as part of a complex ceasefire deal reached with Israel this month.