MEXICO/LONDON/JOHANNESBURG: Voice actor Armando Plata does not recall promoting a shopping mall in Bogota, narrating a porn movie or advertizing a big bank. Yet his voice comes over loud and clear: schmoozing, sighing and selling with neither permission nor payment.
It was the mild, robotic twang - rather than worry over any memory lapse - that alerted Plata to the fact his voice had been quietly cloned via artificial intelligence, robbing the veteran actor of his key asset, artistic choice and vocal rights.
"I believe that the most cloned and artificially used voice in Spanish is mine," said Plata, owner of a deep and lilting voice, 50-year audio career and president of the Colombian Association of Voice Actors.
Now Plata is organizing with voice actors across Latin America to legislate the "right to own one's voice".
And the group is not alone in what is emerging as a global push for human rights against the precipitous rise of AI.
From South Africa to Europe, Japan to the United States, artists are joining forces to protect their jobs, and their souls, from the ramifications of AI that sounds just like them.
The genesis of the voice grab seemed innocent enough.
It was two decades ago that Plata took part in a paid, text-to-speech project for a firm that later - unbeknownst to him - sold its recorded voices to an AI software company.
Plata's voice proved popular, if of no commercial value - to him at least. As it common in the voiceover business, Plata signed no contract so could not then press any lawsuits.
"At one point we will be able to sue companies and push for class actions. But first, we need governments to recognize the ownership of our voices," the voice actor told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.
HUMAN RIGHT TO A VOICE
This year, approximately 500,000 video and voice deepfakes will be shared on social media sites, according to synthetic media detection company DeepMedia.
Cloning a voice used to cost $10,000 in server and AI-training cost; now startups offer it for a few dollars, according to DeepMedia.
Among high-profile cases of vocal appropriation are Morgan Freeman, whose voice and likeness were used in a faked video to criticize President Joe Biden in April 2023.
Given that an AI clone can come in at about half the cost of a voice artist, let alone a celeb, the technology is tempting.
One Colorado voice actor listed on Voices.com marketplace can be hired for a 60-second radio ad for $500; the AI equivalent costs $200 a minute, about $1 a word. Others cost half that.
Speech-generating AI - such as Microsoft's VALL-E language model - works by sifting through reams of data, categorizing how people speak then using an algorithm - known as a neural network - to replicate human vocal patterns and speech characteristics.
After AI-powered audio production companies launched in Chile this year, the national voice actors' association met with lawmakers to discuss voice ownership as a human right.
Voice actors in Colombia have similarly set up a legislative project to establish the human voice as personal patrimony.
Both legislations aim to serve as a basis for future regulations, such as mandating audio watermarks in all materials generated with synthetic voices.
While copyright laws protect works captured on a tangible medium, be it on canvas or stored digitally, voices fall outside the remit.
Some countries also prohibit deepfakes of celebrities, but there are no laws that govern vocal deepfakes specifically.
PERSONAL INFORMATION?
In Africa, voice artists are looking to protect themselves though there are few AI voice models able to prosper in such a rich mix of regional accents and languages, Andrew Sutherland, a South African sound engineer and voice artist, said.
One vehicle may be the South African Protection of Personal Information Act, under which personal data - voice included - cannot be collected, processed or stored without consent.
A voice could be classed as personal and sensitive data as it may show anything from class to age, said Sutherland, so "a legislator could recognise that and protect it on those grounds."
The South African Guild of Actors is lobbying government to enact policies around performer rights, a tactic mirrored by Japan's main industry body for freelance performers, Arts Workers Japan.
Copyright law in Tokyo sides more strongly with AI than does legislation in other countries, letting companies exploit any language, sound or images for data analysis.
Tokyo, however, may have to bring in protections for actors at the start of their career, as AI can generate similar content instantly and preclude their future success, Michihiro Nishi, a partner at law firm Clifford Chance, told the Thomson Reuters Foundation over email.
Japan has also pushed for new G7 legislation while relying on "superficial" old laws to fill the gaps, according to Megumi Morisaki, an actor who is president of Arts Workers Japan.
The result - scant artistic protection, said Morisaki.
WHO RULES IN AI WORLD WITHOUT BORDERS?
Artists across the world are looking to the European Union's AI Act, which classifies AI tools by potential risk, aiming to lay a global baseline for the use of synthetic voices.
"I'll work with a director in the UK, a producer in Canada, a voice actor in Africa, another producer in Sweden, and then I’m in Los Angeles - so who owns what?" said Tim Friedlander, president of the National Association of Voice Actors (NAVA).
"The internet doesn’t know borders or boundaries."
While there was talk in the United States of AI legislation, Friedlander considers it is now at a political stalemate.
The EU must also do more; specifically, NAVA wants AI voices to sit alongside deepfake images in a high-risk group.
"It doesn't just affect well-known voice actors, it affects anybody who has recorded audio anywhere," Friedlander said, referring to the potential for scams or blackmail.
Industry expects the Act to pass this year but there is no deadline, so those at risk are taking their own precautions.
Spanish-speaking voice actors gathered this year to create the United Voices Organization, which aims to negotiate contracts with fair compensation for AI-related projects.
"We want to ensure that voices are used in an ethical manner, guaranteeing contracts of good faith," said its president Daniel Soler de la Prada.
And while NAVA and the Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (SAG-AFTRA) have clauses in their contracts to guard against abuse by AI, fewer than one in five workers in the industry is unionized.
Similarly, voice artists are considered freelancers in South Africa and unable to "unionise and collectively bargain for rights and fair market fees and standards," Sutherland said.
Until legislation is global, advocates for the rights of humans hope platforms will pay named voices instead of those startups that sell AI copies fed by data scraped off the web.
"The ethical piece of AI is so prominent now," said Colin McIlveen, vice president of Voices.com.
In an upbeat note, McIlveen said organizations are now looking to ethical sources for voice acting, something they may not have done two years ago when cheap was better than real.
Even Plata - the accidental porn and ad star - believes AI, if duly regulated, can become a new source of artistic income.
"Imagine that in 15 or 20 years from now, when I'm long gone, my family can still own my voice and have it be productive for one or two more generations," he said.
"This can affect me, but also make me transcend."
Reuters
Sat Oct 28 2023
From South Africa to Europe, Japan to the United States, artists are joining forces to protect their jobs, and their souls, from the ramifications of AI that sounds just like them. - REUTERS
How Indian billionaire Gautam Adani's alleged bribery scheme took off and unraveled
The indictment was unsealed on Nov. 20, prompting a $27 billion plunge in Adani Group companies' market value.
Elon Musk blasts Australia's planned ban on social media for children
Several countries have already vowed to curb social media use by children through legislation, but Australia's policy could become one of the most stringent.
Trump picks Pam Bondi for US Attorney General after Gaetz withdraws
Bondi was the top law enforcement officer of the country's third most populous state from 2011 to 2019, and served on Trump's Opioid and Drug Abuse Commission during his first administration.
Ringgit extends uptrend against greenback in early trade
At 8 am, the local currency climbed to 4.4600/4700 against the greenback.
Lebanon's only burn unit treats toddlers after Israeli strikes
The hospital hallways echo with the screams of children as anxious parents await news from doctors.
AI revolutionising sports to develop world-class athletes
Can a young Orang Asli child from Gua Musang, Kelantan be turned into an Olympic champion in 2036?
Selangor records 1,354 out-of-wedlock teen pregnancies from 2023 to Sept 2024
Anfaal Saari emphasises the seriousness of the issue, especially involving children and teenagers under 18 years old.
ICC issues arrest warrants for Netanyahu and Gallant
The International Criminal Court (ICC) has issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant.
Elon Musk's Neuralink receives Canadian approval for brain chip trial
The study aims to assess the safety and initial functionality of its implant which enables people with quadriplegia.
Guitar bought by Beatles' teenage Harrison for GBP58 sells for more than GBP1 million
A guitar bought by George Harrison for about GBP58 has sold at auction for more than GBP1 million (US$1.27 million), the PA Media news agenc
Duct-taped banana goes for $6.2 mln in Sotheby's art auction
A piece of art that is little more than a banana duct-taped to a wall sold at auction to cryptocurrency entrepreneur.
Australian teen dies from tainted liquor in Laos; fourth suspected victim
Spurious liquor is a problem in Laos, with the govts of Australia and Britain warning citizens to be cautious when taking drinks there.
Woman found in freezer died from chest injuries - Police
Preliminary post-mortem report reveals that the victim died from chest injuries caused by blunt trauma.
Malaysia, Vietnam to further cooperate in multiple sectors - PM
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim says the collaboration will also leverage the ASEAN Energy Grid to foster regional growth.
Australia launches 'landmark' bill to ban social media for children under 16
Australia plans to trial an age-verification system that may include biometrics or govt identification to enforce social media age cut-off.
Court orders PDRM to complete investigations into Beng Hock's death within six months
Judge says the claims and reliefs sought by the applicants are within the domain of public law both in pith and substance.
Zii Jia secures spot in BWF World Tour Finals
This will be Lee Zii Jia's third appearance at the season-ending tournament, following the 2020 and 2021 editions.
PM: Media freedom recognition needs improvement but 3Rs limit action
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim says this stems from a request by the Malay rulers for the government to take a stricter stance on these matters.
Malaysian man to be publicly caned at mosque for Islamic crime of close proximity
This punishment involves caning, but what makes it unusual this time is the judge's decision for it to be conducted publicly.
Son of Norway crown princess detained for one week in rape probe
Marius Borg Hoiby is suspected of having sexual encounters with two women who were either unconscious or incapacitated.