Skip to main content

Global News

The Geneva Conventions and international humanitarian law must be strengthened in a turbulent West Asia and East Asia

Malaysia and ASEAN urged stronger enforcement of humanitarian law to protect civilians and uphold global accountability. - Filepic
Malaysia and ASEAN urged stronger enforcement of humanitarian law to protect civilians and uphold global accountability. - Filepic

AI Brief

  • The article highlights the urgent need to strengthen implementation and compliance with the Geneva Conventions amid ongoing conflicts in West Asia and East Asia.
  • Malaysia and ASEAN are urged to uphold consistent humanitarian standards, prioritise impartial accountability, and enhance regional preparedness for humanitarian law enforcement.
  • Emerging military technologies, such as artificial intelligence and autonomous weapons, require robust safeguards to ensure accountability and protection of civilians in armed conflict.
Advertisement

THE Geneva Conventions were created for a world that had witnessed the consequences of war without restraint. Their central promise remains indispensable: even when states and armed groups resort to force, human dignity must not become negotiable. Civilians must be protected, the wounded must receive care, and those taken prisoner must be treated humanely.

Today, the argument for strengthening these protections is becoming more urgent across West Asia and East Asia. The devastation described in Gaza, as well as concerns about the selective enforcement of international law point to a common danger: rules intended to protect everyone risk becoming privileges extended only to some. For Malaysia and ASEAN, resisting that outcome is both a humanitarian responsibility and a strategic necessity.

The Problem Is Not Merely the Absence of Rules

The Geneva Conventions and the broader framework of international humanitarian law provide the foundation for limiting suffering in armed conflict. Yet legal commitments cannot fulfil their purpose through ratification, diplomatic statements, or expressions of concern alone. Their credibility depends on whether governments and armed actors translate those commitments into conduct, and whether violations attract scrutiny regardless of the perpetrator’s political relationships.

Strengthening international humanitarian law must therefore mean more than negotiating additional texts. It must mean improving implementation, reinforcing humanitarian institutions, supporting credible investigations, and rejecting political interference with accountability. The essential distinction is between strengthening the rules and strengthening compliance. Both deserve attention, but new commitments will achieve little if existing obligations remain subject to geopolitical convenience.

West Asia: Humanitarian Protection Cannot Depend on Alliances

The conflict in Gaza stands at the centre of the warning about selective justice. Its account of civilian suffering, destruction affecting hospitals and schools, and obstruction of humanitarian assistance raises the fundamental question of whether the protections promised by international humanitarian law are being upheld consistently. 

The standard should not change according to the identity of the victims or the strategic importance of the parties involved. Attacks on civilians, mistreatment of detainees, and unlawful interference with humanitarian relief must be assessed against the applicable law and it cannot be excused through competing political narratives. Security concerns cannot become a blanket justification for disregarding humanitarian obligations. Equally, condemning one party’s violations must never imply permission for another party to violate the same rules.

A stronger international response would place civilian protection at the centre of diplomacy. Governments should press for humanitarian access, respect for medical services, humane treatment of all persons held in connection with conflict, and independent examination of alleged violations. The objective should not be to secure rhetorical victories for rival blocs. It should be to reduce suffering and establish that accountability is a legal obligation rather than a diplomatic bargaining chip.

Advertisement

East Asia Must Not Wait for a Humanitarian Catastrophe

For East Asia, the lesson is preventive. The region should not wait for a major armed conflict before asking whether its institutions, armed forces, and civilian authorities are prepared to uphold humanitarian law. The appropriate moment to establish safeguards is before a crisis, when communication remains possible and practical arrangements can be developed without the pressures of active hostilities.

Governments should strengthen military training, legal review, civilian-protection planning, and procedures for investigating alleged violations. They should also develop clearer arrangements for medical assistance, humanitarian access, the protection of essential civilian services, and the humane treatment of detainees. Such preparations need not imply that conflict is inevitable. On the contrary, they would demonstrate that political disagreement and strategic competition do not erase shared responsibilities. Nor should humanitarian dialogue be mistaken for recognition of a rival’s territorial or political claims. Parties can disagree profoundly over sovereignty while still accepting that civilians must not bear unlimited costs.

For Southeast Asia, Myanmar makes this discussion immediate rather than hypothetical. It should be noted that ASEAN’s Five-Point Consensus, and thus continued diplomatic engagement, are important components of the regional response. Those political efforts should be accompanied by a stronger practical emphasis on humanitarian protection.

Malaysia and ASEAN Should Turn Principles into Practice

Malaysia’s strongest contribution would be a consistent position: the same humanitarian standards should apply in West Asia, Southeast Asia, and any future conflict in the wider East Asian region.

Advertisement

That position would require more than condemning abuses abroad. It would also require supporting regional preparedness, credible scrutiny, and humanitarian engagement within ASEAN’s own neighbourhood.

Three priorities should guide this effort. First, Malaysia should champion impartial accountability. Its diplomatic partnerships should become channels for advancing consistent standards rather than reasons to soften them. Calls for investigation should turn on credible allegations and applicable law, not the identity of an ally or adversary. Second, ASEAN should make humanitarian-law preparedness a practical regional undertaking. Member states could work with the International Committee of the Red Cross and relevant ASEAN bodies such as the AHA Centre to develop training, contingency planning, and coordination arrangements within their respective mandates. The goal should be clearer responsibilities before emergencies arise and not merely improvised responses after civilian suffering has escalated. Third, regional diplomacy should distinguish humanitarian access from political endorsement.

Delivering assistance to vulnerable populations should not require approval of the authorities or armed actors controlling the territory in which those populations live. At the same time, humanitarian arrangements must be designed carefully so that aid reaches people in need without becoming an instrument of coercion.

Emerging Weapons Require Stronger Safeguards

The strengthening of international humanitarian law must also address the changing character of warfare. It cannot be denied that artificial intelligence and lethal autonomous weapons are emerging concerns. As such, it cannot be denied that these military technologies must remain subject to meaningful human control and the principles of distinction and proportionality. This in turn should form part of a broader regional discussion about responsibility in warfare. Governments should insist that technological sophistication does not dilute accountability. Decisions involving the use of force must remain subject to clear legal responsibilities, effective oversight, and meaningful scrutiny.

The relevant question is not simply whether a weapon offers a military advantage. It is whether its use can be reconciled with the obligation to distinguish military targets from civilians and to limit civilian harm. West Asian and East Asian governments should participate in shaping these safeguards rather than waiting for standards to be determined elsewhere.

A Shared Interest in Restraint

For Malaysia and other states that place great importance on a rules-based international order, humanitarian law should not be treated as a peripheral moral concern. It belongs at the centre of foreign policy, defence planning, and regional cooperation. The connection between West Asia and East Asia is therefore not that their conflicts, political histories, or security disputes are identical. It is that tolerance of selective compliance in one region weakens confidence in universal protection everywhere.

The Geneva Conventions must not become rules invoked against opponents and set aside for friends. Strengthening them requires political consistency. The ultimate test is straightforward: whether the law protects people when doing so is politically inconvenient. As such, meeting that test is essential to preserving both human dignity and the credibility of international order.
 


Phar Kim Beng, PhD, is Professor of ASEAN Studies and Director of the Institute of Internationaliation and ASEAN Studies (IINTAS) at the International Islamic University Malaysia.

Shahiran Kamaruzaman is an Independent Legal Researcher

** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
 

Must Watch Video