KUALA LUMPUR: Is the AG refuting the constitutional power and authority of the Dewan Rakyat, and of the Agong, to require the PM to test his confidence in Parliament? AG asked
We, the undersigned civil society groups, respond to the Attorney General (AG) Tan Sri Idrus Harun’s statement on 4 September 2021. The AG referred to the operation of Articles 40(2)(a) and 43(2)(a) of the Federal Constitution and drew two conclusions as a result:
(a) His Majesty the Yang di-Pertuan Agong’s power to appoint a prime minister is an absolute power (“kuasa mutlak”); and
(b) Any step by the Dewan Rakyat to verify whether or not Prime Minister Dato’ Seri Ismail Sabri has the confidence of the majority of the members of the Dewan Rakyat through a direct vote in the House would be an attempt to supplant the alleged absolute power of the Agong.
With respect to the office of the Attorney General, Tan Sri Idrus Harun’s conclusions are preposterous. It goes against the spirit and letter of Malaysia’s constitutional democracy and embarrasses the office of the Attorney General.
In light of the same, the public deserves to know Tan Sri Idrus Harun’s advice to the government and the Agong on these issues:
First, is it Tan Sri Idrus Harun’s position that Malaysia is governed by a monarchy with absolute power? As every Malaysian knows, Malaysia practises a system of parliamentary democracy with a constitutional monarchy, under which no institutions have absolute power – whether it is the constitutional monarch, the Executive, Parliament or the Judiciary. All of these institutions exercise their powers based on the limits imposed under the constitution, the principles of constitutional democracy and the rule of law.
His Majesty the Yang di-Pertuan Agong has himself stressed this point to the government on a number of occasions in the past few months, and we refer to, for example, the statements from the Istana Negara dated 29 July 2021 and 18 August 2021.
As eminent scholars have explained, a constitutional monarch’s discretion under Articles 40(2)(a) and 43(2)(a) is a “controlled discretion” because “no discretion can be absolute and must be exercised within the parameters of the law and conventions.” (Faruqi 2020, p. 6).
Second, is Tan Sri Idrus Harun refuting the power and authority of the Dewan Rakyat under the Constitution and established principles of democracy to make and unmake Government through, among others motions of confidence and no confidence?
Even the Federal Court in Nizar v Zambry agreed with the view expressed by Raus Sharif JCA (as he then was) in the appellate court that while a constitutional monarch may rely on external evidence apart from a vote in the legislative body to determine the question of confidence, “actual voting in the [legislative body] is ideal” ( Dato’ Seri Ir Hj Mohammad Nizar bin Jamaluddin v Dato’ Seri Dr Zambry bin Abdul Kadir (Attorney General, intervener) [2010] 2 MLJ 285, at 307 [47 – 48]). It is abundantly clear from the Istana Negara’s statement of 18 August 2021 that His Majesty the Yang di-Pertuan Agong was deeply cognizant of this fact and of the constitutional role of Parliament, as he explicitly advised that the new Prime Minister “must as soon as possible bring a motion of confidence in the Dewan Rakyat to confirm/verify that he has the confidence of a majority of the members of the Dewan Rakyat”.
Third, by trying to frame Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri’s appointment as Prime Minister as an exercise of the Agong’s “absolute power” that cannot be subject to a vote of confidence, is Tan Sri Idrus Harun in fact taking the position that the Agong’s advice in the statement of 18 August 2021 was unconstitutional or should not to be followed?
Fourth, is Tan Sri Idrus Harun refuting the basic principle of parliamentary democracy captured in the spirit if not the words of Articles 40(2)(a) and 43(2)-(4) that the Prime Minister’s obligation to retain the confidence of the majority of the members of the Dewan Rakyat is a continuing obligation throughout his/her term of office?
And therefore, the Dewan Rakyat equally retains the power and authority to express confidence or loss of confidence in the Prime Minister during his/her term of office? In other words, any future move by the members of the Dewan Rakyat to test the confidence in the Prime Minister whether during the sittings in September, October, November or December have absolutely nothing to do with the Agong’s appointment of the Prime Minister in August.
Fifth, by trying to frame Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri’s appointment as Prime Minister as an exercise of the Agong’s “absolute power” that cannot be subject to a vote of confidence, is Tan Sri Idrus Harun attempting to set the stage to suppress legitimate expression of opinion and action that may be taken on the matter?
While we await the AG’s response, we are acutely aware that under the Houses of Parliament (Privileges and Powers) Act 1952 and its Standing Orders, the Dewan Rakyat has the ability to call or summon any person before them, which should include the Attorney General, to answer questions and clarify their position on matters that threaten or call into question the powers, rights and privileges of the House.
The AG's indefensible position on Malaysia's governmental system - that the monarchy is absolute instead of constitutional - calls into question his suitability and tenability for the office. Such high-level fundamental confusion will inevitably pose unnecessary obstacles and distractions to the government's legislative and governance agenda.
This statement is initiated by the Seed Community for a Professional Parliament, a network of individuals active in civil society organisations, think tanks and academia working towards a professional Parliament that facilitates healthy policy competition between parties.
Signed by:
1. Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections (BERSIH 2.0)
2. Bait Al-Amanah
3. Persatuan Pengundi Muda (UNDI18)
4. ENGAGE
5. REFORM
6. IDEAS
Kenyataan Media
Mon Sep 06 2021
Idrus Harun's conclusions goes against the spirit and letter of Malaysias constitutional democracy. Ismail Sabri is seen here announcing the new Cabinet line-up. - BERNAMA
Zayn Malik postpones US tour dates after One Direction bandmate Liam Payne's death
Payne, 31, died on Wednesday after falling from a third-floor hotel room balcony in Buenos Aires, shocking fans of the boy band.
Why voters in a handful of swing states will decide the US presidential election
The contest will almost certainly be decided by just tens of thousands of voters a tiny fraction of the populace in a handful of states.
INSIGHT - Sudan's war risks 'lost generation' of children
A devastating crisis is unfolding in Sudan, where the most vulnerable members of society children are bearing the brunt of the violence.
Former special forces commander Prabowo to take up Indonesian presidency
Indonesia's Prabowo Subianto will take over as president of the world's third-largest democracy after sweeping the country's election with policies like free meals for school children
Who is Prabowo Subianto, incoming president of Indonesia?
A wealthy ex-general with ties to Indonesia's popular outgoing president and its dictatorial past, looks set to be its next leader.
Trump says he would impose tariffs on China if China went into Taiwan
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump said he would impose additional tariffs on China if China were to "go into Taiwan,"
Iran's supreme leader says Hamas leader's death will not halt 'Axis of Resistance'
The "Axis of Resistance", built up with years of Iranian support, includes Hamas, the Lebanese Hezbollah group, the Houthi movement in Yemen, and various Shi'ite groups in Iraq and Syria.
Putin says Russia willing to seek compromises between Iran and Israel
Russia is ready to help seek compromises between arch-foes Israel and Iran, President Vladimir Putin said on Friday, saying these would be difficult but possible.
What proposals will Russia push at the BRICS summit?
The proposal is also to establish a BRICS reinsurance company to allow uninterrupted shipment of goods and key commodities between members.
Indonesia's free meals plan in the spotlight as Prabowo readies for office
Prabowo calls the programme one of the main drivers of economic growth, eventually set to add an estimated 2.5 million jobs.
Astro AWANI's revamped English news website, AWANI International, launches on Oct 21
Astro AWANI's revamped English platform delivers in-depth global news and expert analysis to keep you informed on key developments.
Israeli strikes kill 33 people in Jabalia refugee camp in Gaza, medics say
Residents of Jabalia said Israeli tanks had reached the heart of the camp after pushing through suburbs and residential districts.
Liam Payne's ex-partner calls for media restraint after 'painful' death
Cheryl Tweedy used her statement to urge the media to remember they had a seven-year-old son, Bear, who could read the reports.
Analysts: Indonesia's strong MoF leadership team to boost investor confidence
Sri Mulyani Indrawati as head of Indonesia's Ministry of Finance is expected to instil confidence among investors.
Biden offers both a carrot and a stick to Israel as his term nears an end
Israel has frequently resisted US advice and has caused political difficulties for the Biden administration.
Putin says BRICS will generate most of global economic growth
Russian President Vladimir Putin will host a summit of the group in the city of Kazan on Oct. 22-24.
ISIS Malaysia's perspective of Budget 2025
An excellent rakyat-centric budget under the overarching principle of a caring and humane economy.
Budget 2025: Record increase in STR, SARA aid initiatives
The government will provide a significant boost to the Sumbangan Tunai Rahmah (STR) and Sumbangan Asas Rahmah (SARA) initiatives next year.
Budget 2025: EPF contributions to be made mandatory for foreign workers – PM Anwar
The government plans to make it compulsory for all non-citizen workers to contribute to the Employees Provident Fund (EPF).
What policies to expect from Indonesia's new President Prabowo
Prabowo will be open to foreign investment, his aide has said, such as by offering investors management of airports and sea ports.