Verizon Communications Inc said on Thursday it has a "reasonable basis" to believe Yahoo Inc's massive data breach of email accounts represents a material impact that could allow Verizon to withdraw from its $4.83 billion deal to buy the technology company.
Verizon's general counsel Craig Silliman told reporters at a roundtable in Washington the data breach could trigger a clause in the deal that would allow the U.S. wireless company not to complete it.
"I think we have a reasonable basis to believe right now that the impact is material and we're looking to Yahoo to demonstrate to us the full impact. If they believe that it's not then they'll need to show us that," he said, declining to comment on whether talks are under way to renegotiate the purchase price.
Asked for comment, a Yahoo spokesman said: "We are confident in Yahoo’s value and we continue to work towards integration with Verizon."
The deal has a clause that says Verizon can withdraw if a new event "reasonably can be expected to have a material adverse effect on the business, assets, properties, results of operation or financial condition of the business.”
Silliman said the U.S. Federal Trade Commission has approved Verizon's planned acquisition of Yahoo, but it still needs approval from the European Commission and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is reviewing the proxy.
Verizon has had preliminary briefings from Yahoo but it still needs "significant information" from the company before it makes a final decision on the materiality of the hacking of at least 500 million email accounts, Silliman said.
He said Verizon is "absolutely evaluating (the breach) and will make determinations about whether and how to move forward with the deal based on our evaluation of the materiality."
Yahoo shares ended 1.75 percent lower at $41.62, while Verizon was largely unchanged, closing at $50.29, down 0.02 percent.
Yahoo in September disclosed that it had fallen victim to a data breach in 2014 that compromised users’ names, email addresses, telephone numbers, dates of birth and encrypted passwords.
The company has said the cyber attack was carried out by a “state-sponsored” actor, but some private security experts have challenged that assertion.
Several Democratic senators have pressed Yahoo to reveal more information about the hack and why it took so long to discover.
The internet firm said it learned of the breach this summer while investigating claims of a separate intrusion, but it has not provided a specific timeline of events.
Some analysts suggested Verizon may be trying to get a better price.
Roger Entner, an analyst at Recon Analytics, said "Verizon is rightfully upset about Yahoo not properly disclosing the breach."
He said Yahoo would most likely have to consider renegotiating the price with Verizon, if it came to that.
"I don't think it has much of a choice. Who else would want to buy them?" Entner said.
Experts said bidders who try to extract themselves from mergers using the material adverse clause face an uphill battle. No U.S. company has ever invoked the clause successfully in court to get out of a deal.
In 2013, Cooper Tire & Rubber company got cold feet about a $2.5 billion sale to Apollo Tyres and argued in the Delaware Court of Chancery that Apollo had seen a material adverse change related to union issues at a subsidiary of the company. The court rejected Cooper Tire’s claims and the deal fell apart.
A Delaware court ruled in 2001 that poultry producer Tyson Foods Inc could not terminate its merger with beef producer IBP Inc over accounting irregularities. The court said the shortfall was not due to a long-term problem.
Reuters
Fri Oct 14 2016
Yahoo spokesman says: "We are confident in Yahoos value and we continue to work towards integration with Verizon." - EPA/MICHAEL NELSON/File
Brazil's Lula seen walking for first time since surgeries
Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva underwent two operations in Sao Paulo's Sirio-Libanes Hospital to relieve and prevent bleeding in his skull.
France's Macron names veteran centrist ally Bayrou as prime minister
Francois Bayrou's top priority will be passing a special law to roll over the 2024 budget, with a nastier battle over 2025 legislation.
Google says it has cracked a quantum computing challenge with new chip
It solves a computing problem in five minutes that would take a classical computer more time than the history of the universe, Google says.
Singapore, Vietnam firms in talks for new undersea cables, sources say
A plan is being discussed to lay a cable linking Vietnam directly to Singapore, according to five sources involved or briefed on the matter.
Batu Puteh RCI not an act of revenge - PM
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim says the narrative of vengeance should not be raised in the issue, especially by the opposition.
Four days of continuous rain expected in Kelantan, Terengganu from Dec 16 - MetMalaysia
MetMalaysia says that the Hulu Perak district in Perak will also experience similar weather conditions.
No official denial on donation from Saudi royals, says Najib
This absence of denial supports my genuine belief that the funds were legitimate donations, says Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak.
Millions of Malaysians are inspired to #ThinkTwice with TikTok
The campaign educates on Community Guidelines, safety features, and fosters a kinder, more positive online community.
BWF World Tour Finals: Two Malaysians mixed doubles pairs advance to semi-finals
Chen Tang Jie-Toh Ee Wei and Goh Soon Huat-Shevon Lai advances to semi-finals of the 2024 BWF World Tour Finals in Hangzhou, China.
Flash flood hits school in Saratok, 50 students and staff evacuated
Floodwaters submerge the school's hall and pre-school classes up to almost one metre deep.
What do we know about investigations faced by South Korean President Yoon?
Prosecutors, the police and Corruption Investigation Office for High-ranking Officials launches probes into Yoon Suk-yeol and the officials.
Google launches AI initiatives at Malaysia’s National AI Office opening
The initiatives aim to enhance productivity and policy-making through generative AI, said the tech giant in a press release today.
Soccer - Saudi Arabia's human rights record under fire after World Cup bid win
FIFA gave the bid a high technical score, a move Amnesty calls an "astonishing whitewash" of the country's human rights record.
Brazil's Lula has head drain removed after second surgery, doctors say
Lula remains "lucid and speaking normally", the doctors say in a new medical note, adding the drain was removed without complications.
[COLUMNIST] Unlocking opportunities: Strengthening Russia-ASEAN partnerships
Collaboration with Russia and China would enable Malaysia to tap into their advanced technologies and extensive expertise.
Elon Musk's net worth tops $400 bil, Forbes billionaires list shows
His wealth mainly consists of shares in the electric car manufacturer Tesla and the aerospace company SpaceX.
Third session of 15th Parliament adjourns sine die after passing 25 bills, including Budget 2025
For the first time, the chairmen of Special Select Committees were given the platform to present and explain committee statements.
South Korea opposition leader Lee says impeaching Yoon best way to restore order
South Korean Democratic Party leader Lee Jae-myung calls President Yoon Suk-Yeol's remarks "a declaration of war" against the people.
Man with criminal record killed in police shootout in Jeram Pasu
The suspect had 17 previous criminal records, including gang robbery and firearms, as well as seven drug-related cases, says police.
Breaking silence on possible drills, China says will not be soft on Taiwan independence activities
China asserts it decides on drills, vowing the military "won't be absent" in fighting separatist forces.